6 Best Alternatives to Ollie Dog Food (2026): Tested on Picky Dogs
Are you looking to cancel, pause or rethink your Ollie dog food subscription in favor of a better alternative, whether that’s dry, fresh or raw dog food? I’ve uncovered the best alternatives after testing over 30 different dog food brands on my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs.
Ollie is a leading dog food company in the United States with an established fresh dog food range, complemented by baked dry dog food that offers convenience and value.
I first reviewed Ollie in 2019 when I was looking to unearth fresh dog food to keep my picky eater, Skye, motivated at mealtime. At that time, they had just three fresh recipes.
When we returned to California in 2023, we started testing a variety of different dog food formats, including air-dried, fresh, freeze-dried, raw, and Ollie’s baked food.
If you want a fresh alternative, The Farmer’s Dog is a great choice, and Skye enjoyed it. Sundays offers air-dried food that rivals Ollie’s dry recipes, with a treat-like texture.
But for dog owners with a picky eater like me, We Feed Raw is my top choice because their food has transformed Skye from a picky dog into a food-motivated pup.
In this guide, I’ll share my best alternatives to Ollie based on my real testing on my Klee Kai dogs, monthly costs, convenience, and overall experience.
Show table of contents Hide table of contents
Watch: The Best Ollie Alternatives Tested with Our Dogs
Best Air-Dried Alternative: Sundays
If your dog likes dry dog food but you want something a little more appetizing than their baked dry food, I’d consider Sundays dog food. They offer a range of air-dried food with a jerky-like texture. I found this really appealed to Skye, encouraging my picky eater to finish her portion at mealtime. We fed Sundays for over a year when we returned to California, with good success.
Sundays has vet-formulated recipes made with high-quality ingredients and customized to meet your dog’s needs based on your answers in their sign-up questionnaire. It’s shelf-stable, which means it doesn’t require fridge or freezer space. They currently offer three recipes: beef, chicken, and turkey. This range hasn’t expanded in the past three years, unlike other brands.
Discover my Sundays alternatives guide.
How Sundays compares to Ollie
Sundays has three air-dried recipes, while Ollie has two baked recipes. However, you can combine dry and fresh if you sign up for Ollie. My Klee Kai clearly preferred Sundays’ texture over Ollie’s baked food. Sundays has 90% meat content, which I believe helped to entice Skye to consistently finish her portion. You can find Ollie at your local pet store, but you can only buy Sundays through their website.
Best Fresh Alternative: The Farmer’s Dog
If your dog has fully converted to the fresh dog food, you might be eager to stick with this pet food format. Farmer’s Dog is my top pick for fresh dog food because I believe it offers the best overall value. They have four recipes (grain and grain-free versions). They use high-quality ingredients in recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists. What stood out about The Farmer’s Dog is the customization, personalization, and pre-portioning.
Here are some Farmer’s Dog alternatives.
How Farmer’s Dog compares to Ollie
The Farmer’s Dog offers a more customized experience than Ollie. I love that Copper and Skye received individual meal packets from The Farmer’s Dog, something we didn’t receive from Ollie. The Farmer’s Dog includes a handy portion guideline on the front of each meal packet; Ollie doesn’t. The texture was notably different. I found Ollie denser and drier, which didn’t appeal to Skye. Finally, The Farmer’s Dog cost me $251 a month, while Ollie charged $310 a month.
Best Raw Alternative: We Feed Raw
If you’ve got an extremely fussy eater and Ollie’s food didn’t consistently satisfy your pup, I’d recommend We Feed Raw. Skye has transformed since we switched to their frozen raw food. She’s consistently finished her We Feed Raw food for the past two years – something that never happened before with any other brand. Their recipes are formulated by a vet and a PhD animal nutritionist. With peel-back pouches, I split a pouch between Copper and Skye every mealtime. So it’s pretty easy to prepare.
How We Feed Raw frozen raw compares to Ollie
Both Ollie and We Feed Raw offer five recipes for their fresh and raw options, respectively. Both provide meal containers to store half-opened packets and prevent fridge mess. My We Feed Raw price is $280, which is $30 less than Ollie. But the biggest difference is my Klee Kai’s reaction. Copper and Skye clearly preferred their frozen raw food to Ollie’s fresh recipes.
Best Freeze-Dried Alternative: We Feed Raw
We Feed Raw rivals Ollie by also offering a dry food alternative. We have fed their freeze-dried recipes to our Alaskan Klee Kai, and they like it. They’ve got two recipes: beef and chicken. It’s handy if you want the benefits of frozen raw without the hassle. You can simply reseal the bag and pop it back in the cupboard. I appreciate the simplicity of the ingredients.
How We Feed Raw freeze-dried compares to Ollie
Ollie and We Feed Raw offer dry food options for pet parents who don’t want the hassle of fridge and freezer space, thawing meal packets, the mess, and the higher cost. The texture differs: Ollie’s baked food is harder, while We Feed Raw’s freeze-dried food is softer. So keep that in mind if your dog has a preference. My Klee Kai preferred freeze-dried when we tested both.
Best Value Alternative: UnKibble
UnKibble is Spot & Tango’s answer to dry food. They use human-grade ingredients in vet-formulated recipes. They’ve got three recipes: beef, salmon and cod. Unfortunately, my dogs loved a now-discontinued chicken recipe. I appreciate the transparent approach to labeling: you can clearly see what goes into your dog’s food on the front of the bag. UnKibble is the only dog food brand I’ve reviewed that includes a customized scooper (Copper and Skye each got their own).
How does UnKibble compare to Ollie
UnKibble has a softer texture and doesn’t look like traditional dry food when compared to Ollie’s baked food. They offer an additional recipe, although they’ve got two fish. Ollie only has two recipes but covers beef and chicken. UnKibble’s custom scooper is a big differentiator for me, especially for convenience. The other big difference is the price. UnKibble is the most affordable of all the dog food subscriptions I’ve reviewed at $164.40 a month.
Best Dry+Fresh Alternative: The Pets Table
The Pets Table is perhaps the most natural alternative to Ollie, since they offer both fresh and dry dog food. When I first reviewed them back in 2023, they had three fresh and two baked recipes. In 2026, they’ve got five fresh and three baked options. You can get a fresh, air-dried, half fresh and mixed plan. This caters to the different prefences of dogs and the varying budgets of pet owners.
How does The Pets Table compare to Ollie
The Pets Table offers a more flexible dog food subscription experience than Ollie. They’ve got four different plans. They’ve got more recipes. My dogs preferred The Pets Table’s air-dried texture over Ollie’s baked food. I found The Pets Table’s fresh dog food to be more mushy than Ollie’s dense fresh food. Copper and Skye preferred The Pets Table when it came to fresh.
Reasons You Might Want to Stick with Ollie
Before you cancel your Ollie subscription, consider whether you’re making the right decision for you and your dog.
If your dog is currently enjoying Ollie, it might be safer to stick with their food. This is especially worth considering if you have a fussy dog like me.
Read my dedicated Ollie dog food review.
Ollie’s baked recipes have a different texture than other dry food brands, such as Sundays, UnKibble, We Feed Raw, and The Pets Table.
If you don’t want to be tied to a subscription, remember that You can find Ollie at your local pet store, giving you flexibility.
Ollie Alternatives FAQ
Some pet owners switch away from Ollie because of subscription costs, the hassle of making space in their fridge and freezer, and their dog getting tired of the food.
The Farmer’s Dog is the closest comparison to Ollie Fresh because it offers fresh dog food recipes, stored in meal packets, and requires cold storage. Some dog owners prefer Farmer’s Dog for better customization and feeding experience.
You can combine Ollie’s baked and fresh recipes, and you can do the same with The Pets Table. In my case, Copper and Skye eat frozen raw and freeze-dried as a topper.
Wrapping Up
Ollie remains one of the most popular dog food options for pet parents in the United States.
However, you may have decided to seek an alternative for one of many reasons, such as cost, hassle, and your dog’s fussiness.
If so, my top overall pick is We Feed Raw if you’ve got an extremely fussy eater like Skye. Their food has transformed her appetite and energy.
For fresh dog food, The Farmer’s Dog is my top pick because their fresh food recipes are similar but at a more affordable price and with a better experience.
Finally, Sundays’ air-dried food is a great alternative to Ollie’s baked recipes, and my Klee Kai loved the high meat content and jerky-like texture.