6 Best Alternatives To UnKibble (2026): Tested On Picky Dogs
Are you looking to cancel your UnKibble subscription in favor of a better alternative? After genuine testing of over 30 different dog food brands on my picky Alaskan Klee Kai dogs, including air-dried, freeze-dried, fresh and raw dog food, I’ve got some good alternatives to consider if you’re ready to make a change.
Since returning to California from the UK in 2023, I’ve been on the search for the best dog food for Copper and Skye, especially considering my female Alaskan Klee Kai is a really fussy eater who used to regularly refuse her food at mealtime.
I’ve been reviewing dog food for the past 10 years, and I’ve tested all the big-name brands in the United States, giving me a unique insight into the ordering experience, convenience and storage, value, and suitability for picky dogs like Skye.
UnKibble is a great option if you’re looking to get all the benefits of fresh dog food in a dry food format, allowing your dog to get a high-quality diet, customized to meet their needs, but without the hassle of fresh or raw dog food.
However, you may be ready to make a change, whether you want to try fresh dog food, you’re ready to test a raw fed diet for the first time, or you want to switch to a different dry dog food brand.
Show table of contents Hide table of contents
Best Air-Dried Alternative: Sundays For Dogs
Sundays provides air-dried dog food that is ideal for pups who like dry food and pet owners who don’t want the hassle of fresh or raw food. Sundays offers three different recipes: beef, chicken and turkey. Their vet-formulated recipes have a high meat content and jerky-like texture, which appealed to Skye. I like to use it as a topper these days, although I previously fed it as their main meal between 2023 and 2024.
How Sundays compares to UnKibble
Sundays has more of a treat-like texture compared to UnKibble, which is more like traditional pet food morsels. They both offer three recipes, but UnKibble has one fish flavor. My dogs preferred Sundays’ beef, chicken and turkey over UnKibble’s cod and salmon recipes. UnKibble provided a custom scooper for Copper and Skye individually, something Sundays doesn’t do. There’s a noticeable price difference. UnKibble costs $164.40 a month ($140 in 2023), Sundays charged me $221 ($139 in 2023).
If you’ve tried Sundays dog food before, you can discover my best alternatives to their air-dried food.
Best Freeze-Dried Raw Alternative: We Feed Raw
We Feed Raw is a raw dog food company that has a range of freeze-dried recipes. It’s a great alternative for pet parents who don’t want the hassle of storing, thawing and preparing frozen raw food. Copper and Skye consistently eat their beef and chicken recipes, which have been formulated by a vet and PhD animal nutritionist. I’ve included this as my freeze-dried pick because my Klee Kai show lots of mealtime excitement when it’s in their bowl.
How We Feed Raw freeze-dried compares to UnKibble
UnKibble offers one more recipe than We Feed Raw, which might appeal to picky dogs. However, We Feed Raw has formulated two freeze-dried recipes using the most popular proteins. One of UnKibble’s three recipes is fish. We Feed Raw uses a generic scooper, which is an area where they can improve. Copper and Skye’s freeze-dried food is priced at $202.20 a month, which is nearly $40 more than UnKibble.
Best Dehydrated Alternative: The Honest Kitchen
For pet parents who don’t want to veer away from dry dog food but are ready to move away from UnKibble, you may want to consider The Honest Kitchen. They’ve got a dehydrated range that appealed to my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs. They’ve got seven recipes, including a formulation for senior dogs. Pet parents will need to prepare their dog’s portion by adding warm water to the dehydrated food and waiting three minutes for it to rehydrate. I liked getting the benefits of fresh without needing fridge or freezer space.
How does The Honest Kitchen compare to UnKibble
UnKibble doesn’t require any work from the point of view of the pet owners. It’s really as simple as scoop and serve. Dog owners need to take a few extra steps to prepare The Honest Kitchen. However, The Honest Kitchen is easier to store because the food is dehydrated and takes up less space in the cupboard. I was surprised to see my Klee Kai tuck into their dehydrated food with such enthusiasm. They’ve got four more recipes than UnKibble.
Best Fresh Alternative: The Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog offers fresh dog food for pet owners who are ready to give their pet food format a try. It’s the best value of all the fresh dog food companies I’ve reviewed. They’ve got four recipes (grain and grain-free), individually labeled Copper and Skye’s pouches, attach a pre-portioned daily guide, and my Klee Kai happily ate it. If you’ve got a fussy eater, we had pretty good success with Skye on The Farmer’s Dog. They prefer it to Ollie and Nom Nom (other fresh brands).
How does The Farmer’s Dog compare to UnKibble
The Farmer’s Dog differs from UnKibble because their food is fresh instead of dry. The Farmer’s Dog has one more recipe on offer than UnKibble, with extra variety potentially appealing to picky eaters. You do need freezer space, you’re required to keep a pouch or two thawed, and you’ll have to store leftovers in the fridge. UnKibble is shelf stable and can be kept in the cupboard. The Farmer’s Dog charged me $251 a month for their fresh food, which is $87 more than UnKibble.
Do you want a different fresh dog food option? Here are some Farmer’s Dog alternatives.
Best Frozen Raw Alternative: We Feed Raw
We’ve already discussed their freeze-dried food, but We Feed Raw offers frozen raw recipes too. This is the food I currently feed to my Alaskan Klee Kai. It’s transformed Skye from a fussy eater into a food-motivated dog. I’ve never seen her show so much consistent mealtime excitement. They’ve got five recipes and use peel-back pouches, and I split a meal packet between Copper and Skye every mealtime. We’ve had two years of continued success.
How We Feed Raw frozen raw compares to UnKibble
We Feed Raw has five different proteins on offer, which is notably more than UnKibble. There’s no doubt that We Feed Raw is more hassle than UnKibble because you’ll need freezer space and stay on top of keeping some pouches thawed. I do like that you can add toppers and supplements to frozen raw more easily than dry food. I pay $280 a month for frozen raw, which is substantially more than my UnKibble cost.
Best Dry+Fresh Alternative: The Pets Table
I’ve included The Pets Table because they allow dog owners to combine fresh and dry food together in the same subscription. If you’re looking for an alternative to UnKibble, you may want to try fresh with the safety net of having dry food still included in your dog’s bowl. They’ve got five fresh and three air-dried recipes. It’s definitely appealing to have so many options available.
How does The Pets Table compare to UnKibble
The Pets Table provides air-dried and fresh recipes that you can easily combine as part of the same subscription plan. I reached out to Spot & Tango to see if it’s possible to combine their fresh meals with UnKibble. They confirmed that it is but you have to work with customer service. Copper and Skye liked the air-dried food from The Pets Table. However, UnKibble is more convenient with their custom scooper.
Reasons You Might Want to Stick with UnKibble
While I’ve shared some great alternatives if you’re ready to move away from UnKibble, I do believe there are some reasons to stick with their dry food.
UnKibble does some things differently compared to other pet food companies, namely the custom scooper which I’ve not experienced anywhere else.
By the way, Copper and Skye got their own scooper based on my answers in their signup questionnaire: Skye’s was bigger than Copper’s because he needs to lose weight.
They’re still unbeaten on price. UnKibble costs $164.40 a month for Copper and Skye, which is only a $24.40 increase from when I reviewed their food back in 2023.
I appreciate their transparent labeling which makes it easy to see exactly what’s gone into your dog’s recipes: I could easily recognize the ingredients.
UnKibble Alternatives FAQ
The most common reason dog owners move away from UnKibble is palatability and texture. While my dogs enjoyed it for the most part, I do believe they prefer the texture of air-dried, fresh and raw food.
Having reviewed over 30 different dog food brands, I believe We Feed Raw’s freeze-dried food is most similar. It looks quite similar in shape and texture. You could also consider air-dried food with a treat-like texture.
The great thing about dehydrated dog food such as The Honest Kitchen is that it helps to keep dogs hydrated. By adding warm water to the dehydrated food, pet owners can create a tempting aroma. There are also urinary health benefits.
Having reviewed over 30 dog food subscription companies in the United States, I’m yet to encounter a brand that can beat my monthly price with UnKibble.
Wrapping Up
We’ve reached the end of our UnKibble alternatives article. We’ve shared six potential options if you’re ready to make a change.
My top pick would be We Feed Raw’s frozen raw food based on the outstanding success we’ve had introducing their food to Skye.
Our nine-year-old Klee Kai never consistently ate the same food until we made the switch to We Feed Raw. We haven’t looked back.
If you’re ready to embrace fresh dog food, The Farmer’s Dog followed through on personalization, customization, and overall value.
For dog owners who want to stick to dry dog food and don’t want the stress of dealing with fresh or raw food, we suggest Sundays.
Copper and Skye loved the treat-like texture, although freeze-dried food allows you to get the benefits of raw food in a convenient way.