Last Updated on July 3, 2024 by Kieran Beckles
Are you ready to switch to fresh dog food, but you can’t decide between Sundays For Dogs and Ollie?
Sundays For Dogs and Ollie offer high-quality food to dogs in the USA – but there are some key differences between these two dog food delivery services.
Having moved to the USA in 2023, I’ve been on a journey with my Alaskan Klee Kai, trying to find the best dog food that’ll keep Copper and Skye happy, healthy and food-motivated at mealtime.
I’ve been feeding balanced and complete meals to my Alaskan Klee Kai for the past five years – and I’m excited you’re ready to join me in ditching kibble in favor of one of these pet food delivery services.
In this comparison article, I’ll be taking a look at Sundays For Dogs and Ollie to share my experience with these dog food brands to help inform your decision if you can’t pick between them.
Sundays Food For Dogs Or Ollie: Our recommendation
I’ll cut right to the chase before diving in-depth into these brands. Who do we recommend? My pick would be Sundays based on my experience.
Sundays For Dogs offers air-dried dog food that contains a lot of meat and superfoods, while Ollie provides fresh meals and dry food that use whole, human-grade ingredients.
Although Sundays For Dogs offers air-dried food, they’ve got a significantly higher percentage of protein (90%) in their jerky-like dog food. This is considerably more than Ollie based on the nutritional information provided on their website for their five meals.
By virtue of being air-dried dog food, Sundays offer a more convenient way to feed your pet. If you’ve got limited space in your freezer and a fridge full of leftovers, you might not want the headache of trying to store loads of dog food packets. Sundays offer shelf-stable dog food that can simply be placed in the cupboard once you’re done.
Having said that, Ollie does provide a brilliant storage container and scooper in your first delivery, allowing you to empty some meal packets into the container and keep it in the fridge. I haven’t seen any other dog food delivery service show such an initiative, so credit to Ollie for trying to make fresh dog food as least messy as possible.
There’s no escaping that air-dried dog food is less messy than fresh dog food. When it comes time to prepare your dog’s meals, you simply check the feeding guidelines and scoop some air-dried dog food into your dog’s bowl.
With Ollie’s packets, you have to cut them open and move them into the container before using the scooper to place them in your dog’s bowls. If you’re feeding a combination of fresh and dry food, you can enjoy some of the convenience of dry food, but you’re still dealing with fresh meals.
There’s also the price to consider. Sundays For Dogs claims that their air-dried dog food is 40% cheaper than fresh dog food. I put this to the test to see how much I could expect to pay for Copper and Skye each week and the total for the month when feeding Sundays and Ollie.
If I signed up for Sundays, I could expect to pay $138 every month. That equates to around $35 every week or $5 a day. Alternatively, I’d need to cough up $219.60 every month. That works out at $54.90 per week or $8 a day. Based on my calculation, in this case, Sundays are just shy of 40% cheaper than Ollie!
So my four key differences would be the type of dog food (Sundays is air-dried dog food, and Ollie is fresh dog food), the way it needs to be stored, the preparation and the price.
I was pleasantly surprised by how much my dogs enjoyed Sundays compared to the dry food that they’ve eaten in the past. Copper and Skye both finished their bowls even though Skye wouldn’t typically be the biggest fan of dry dog food such as traditional kibble.
I continued to feed them air-dried dog food for the best part of a month before my Sundays ran out.
Ollie did look like dog food rather than being fit for human consumption. While I know it’s ultimately a dog food delivery company, some human-grade pet food has recipes that do look like something you or I would eat.
My Alaskan Klee Kai enjoyed some of their Ollie meals. Skye did have a couple of days where she’d leave a little, or she wouldn’t come over immediately for her food, but for the most part, it passed the taste test.
Copper and Skye appeared to enjoy Sundays’s air-dried food more than Ollie’s fresh and baked meals, while I preferred the convenience of simply storing the air-dried food in the cupboard to keep my freezer free of pet food.
There’s also the cost factor to consider. Sundays are significantly cheaper than Ollie, which is huge for dog owners like me who have a family and are trying to make a budget to cover all life’s necessities.
While I would typically always go for fresh meals over dry food for my dogs, I’d recommend Sundays over Ollie based on the factors listed above.
Who Are Sundays For Dogs?
Sundays For Dogs has been creating healthy dog food since launching in 2020. Their dog food is made with human-grade ingredients such as USDA-quality meat, fresh fruit and fresh vegetables.
You’ll be happy to learn that Sundays’ dog food doesn’t contain any additives, preservatives or any other nasties. Sundays Food For Dogs’ recipes are made up of 90% protein, which is significantly higher than a lot of dry food and fresh dog food brands.
So if you want your dog to enjoy a high-protein diet along with superfoods in recipes formulated by veterinarians, Sundays’ dog food is a good choice. They use an air-drying process that locks in flavours and nutrients. So if you’ve got picky eaters at home like my Alaskan Klee Kai, Sundays’ dog food should have great flavour and taste.
To get started, you need to complete their sign-up questionnaire so Sundays can tailor your dog’s air dried food accordingly. You can still decide which recipes you’d prefer for your dog before Sundays reveal the cost of your subscription plan.
As Sundays offer air dried dog food rather than fresh food, it’s more affordable and your budget should take less of a hit. They claim Sundays’ dog food costs 40% less than fresh-cooked (which we saw above is actually true!).
Sundays Food For Dogs can be stored in the cupboard rather than taking up fridge or freezer space, making it really convenient for pet parents.
Who Are Ollie?
Ollie is another relatively experienced dog food delivery service in the USA who’ve been providing fresh food and baked food to pups for over seven years in the States.
They have created a range of fresh meals and baked food recipes that cater to pet owners who want their dogs to eat fresh food rather than dry or wet food for dogs.
Ollie is so confident about the quality of the dog food they claim on their website that their fresh recipes “are the closest thing to feeding your dog human food”.
At the time of writing, this dog food delivery service offer five fresh recipes for dogs and two baked recipes.
Ollie’s recipes include Fresh Beef With Sweet Potatoes, Fresh Chicken With Carrots, Fresh Turkey With Blueberries, Fresh Lamb With Cranberries and Fresh Pork With Apples.
Ollie explain the ingredients are minimally processed and their dog food doesn’t contain any preservatives or harmful fillers.
Just like Sundays Food For Dogs, Ollie will require pet parents to get started by filling out a questionnaire to allow the dog food delivery company to get to know your dog better.
They’ll tailor your dog’s diet to meet their specific needs before your pup’s fresh dog food is shipped directly to your door. You’ll need to store the dog food in the freezer and keep a couple of defrosted packets in the fridge ready to serve.
Where Can I Buy Sundays Food For Dogs And Ollie?
You can only order Sundays For Dogs direct from their website.
To start your order with Sundays, you can click this link or the button below and save 50% on your first order!
Where Can I Buy Ollie?
Ollie’s fresh meals can only be ordered by heading to their website and filling out their questionnaire.
If you’ve decided to give Ollie a go, you can save 50% when you click this link or the button below.
Wrapping Up
We’ve reached the end of our Sundays For Dogs and Ollie comparison article.
As I discussed above, there are four key differences between Sundays and Ollie. There are the pet food format, storage, preparation and price.
Based upon these factors, I prefer Sundays For Dogs for the sheer convenience of feeding healthy food that can be stored in the cupboard and doesn’t cost the price of a car loan each month.
Don't forget you can save 50% on your first Sundays order by clicking here and using code "LIFEWITHKLEEKAI" at the checkout.
Kieran runs Life With Klee Kai on social media and other online platforms alongside his wife Yasmin. With over 10 years of experience as a journalist and a passionate dog owner, Kieran loves to combine his passion for pets and writing to share useful insights and product reviews to help other dog owners.