Last Updated on September 23, 2024 by Kieran Beckles
Are you ready to give a dog food subscription service a try, but you can’t decide between The Pets Table and Ollie?
I’ve been feeding human-grade fresh dog food to my Alaskan Klee Kai for the past two years since moving to the USA.
My fussy eater, Skye, is picky about her food but I’ve found some dog food brands that my Klee Kai will always get excited to eat.
In this article, I’m going to be taking a look at The Pets Table and Ollie, sharing my Klee Kai’s verdict and my verdict, and where you can buy their food.
With the introduction out of the way, let’s start by taking a look at which of these two dog food companies I’d recommend to my fellow pet owners.
Cut to the chase: You can save 50% on your first order of Ollie when you click this link.
The Pets Table Vs Ollie: Who Do We Recommend?
We’ll get right down to business and share our pick if you’re stuck between these two dog food companies. My recommendation would be Ollie.
I like that the Ollie offers baked and fresh recipes, which you can order separately or combine to provide your pup with different textures at mealtime.
Ollie has a good range of fresh recipes to cater to picky eaters. Copper and Skye were big fans of the chicken, beef and pork recipes.
From a dog owner’s perspective, I liked that Ollie provided a scooper and container to cut down on the mess at mealtime.
Ollie’s meal packets were more convenient to use and stored a lot more food. The Pets Table’s meal packets were poorly designed, and difficult to scrape out food.
Copper and Skye tended to finish their Ollie’s meals but didn’t really like The Pets Table. I wasn’t surprised because The Pets Table looked more unappealing.
There wasn’t a lot of difference in price. Ollie cost me $219.60 a month, which was $2.04 more than my subscription to The Pets Table.
I believe Ollie was a bigger hit with my Klee Kai, made my life a little easier as a pet owner and offers a more refined pet-food service. So I’d recommend Ollie!
Who Is Ollie?
Ollie is an experienced dog food company that offers baked recipes and fresh dog food recipes to pet owners in the USA.
They introduced baked recipes in 2023 to cater to dog parents who want to stick to feeding dry dog food to their canine companions.
Ollie offers five fresh recipes (beef, chicken, lamb, pork, and turkey), which is more than any other fresh dog food company in the USA. They’ve got two baked recipes (beef and chicken).
Dog owners are required to fill out their sign-up questionnaire to give Ollie some basic details about their pets, such as age, weight, breed, activity level and more.
However, I was a little disappointed Ollie didn’t take more steps to customize Skye and Copper’s respective meals seeing as they’ve got different weight goals.
I did appreciate that Ollie provided a scooper and a meal container with my first delivery to provide me with a handy place to store my fresh Ollie meals in the fridge.
Who Is The Pets Table?
The Pets Table is a new player in the dog food subscription market, but the pet food brand is powered by the popular meal service company Hello Fresh.
Having provided Americans with a convenient way to eat healthy meals, The Pets Table is their equivalent offering for dogs in the USA.
The Pets Table offers fresh and dry dog food as part of their subscription service. They’ve got three recipes – Chicken Casserole, Turkey Casserole and Beef Stew. They’ve got two air-dried dog food recipes – Beef & Berries and Chicken & Sweet Potato.
Copper and Skye typically enjoy these two pet food formats – we fed them fresh food when we lived in the UK, and we’ve fed this air-dried dog food brand since moving back to the USA in 2023.
If you’ve ever ordered from Hello Fresh, you’ll be familiar with The Pets Table sign-up questionnaire. It was similar! However, you need to fill out their questionnaire and set up separate plans if you’ve got multiple dogs, which I consider inconvenient.
The Pets Table stores their fresh food in narrow meal packets, and while they offer a portion guideline on each meal packet, they’re rendered useless because the food is difficult to get out of the meal packet.
I found their meal pouches were hard to use and left a lot of mess in my fridge. The Pets Table do offer a meal container, so you can store their meal packets in the container, although the pouches are longer than the container!
Where To Buy Ollie
You can sign up to receive your first order of Ollie through their website where you’ll need to complete their sign-up questionnaire.
We’ve secured a 50% discount for our Life With Klee Kai if you’d like to place an order with Ollie.
Where To Buy The Pets Table
To get started with The Pets Table, you’ll need to head to their website and answer their questions before completing the sign-up process.
We can offer new The Pets Table customers 50% off your first box and 20% off your second box.
Wrapping Up
We’ve reached the end of our comparison article, taking a look at Ollie and The Pets Table.
My recommendation to our readers would be Ollie based on my overall experience with these two dog food subscription companies.
Copper and Skye preferred Ollie over The Pets Table, which is the biggest factor in my decision, but I preferred Ollie from a dog owner’s viewpoint, too.
Kieran runs Life With Klee Kai on social media and other online platforms alongside his wife Yasmin. With over 10 years of experience as a journalist and a passionate dog owner, Kieran loves to combine his passion for pets and writing to share useful insights and product reviews to help other dog owners.