Tally’s Ranch Vs UnKibble (2026): Which Dog Food Is Better?

Last Updated on September 13, 2026 by Kieran Beckles

So you want to switch dog food, but you can’t decide between Tally’s Ranch and UnKibble. I look at the differences in recipes, convenience, price, and which my picky eater preferred.

It’s hard to decide which pet food brand is best for your canine companion when there are so many similar options available online and in stores.

UnKibble is the most affordable dog food subscription service among the dog food brands I’ve reviewed. They also provide a custom scooper, which offers more personalization than most competitors. My Klee Kai dogs enjoyed their recipes, especially the beef flavor.

Tally’s Ranch is relatively new to the market and provides freeze-dried raw food. They don’t have as many recipes as UnKibble, and they’re more expensive, but my mini huskies enjoy the freeze-dried format. While they offer a scooper, it isn’t customized.

In this article, I’m going to share the key differences between Tally’s Ranch and UnKibble to help pet owners who can’t decide between these two dry dog food brands.

Tally’s Ranch vs UnKibble Comparison Table

Tally’s Ranch vs UnKibble: Our Recommendation

I don’t want to waste your time, so I’m going to share my pick between these dry dog food companies. I’d recommend UnKibble based on three years of testing.

It’s a hard decision, but I believe Spot and Tango offers a more well-rounded dog food subscription service at the moment, with more recipes and a custom scooper.

I like that Spot and Tango offers three dry food recipes so I can vary Skye’s meals. She’s my picky eater, and I find she easily gets bored when I feed her the same recipes over and over.

They offer a customized meal plan that results in a scooper designed with your dog’s daily dietary requirements in mind. Spot and Tango follow through with the personalized element of their business.

Spot and Tango cost $164 a month to feed to my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs. Tally’s Ranch, on the other hand, quoted $219 a month. That’s a price difference of $55 a month (or $660 a year).

If you’ve been reading my reviews over the past year or so, you’ll know we predominantly feed raw food with dry food as a topper.

I like that Tally’s Ranch uses a freeze-dried method, giving dog owners a way to let their dogs enjoy the benefits of raw without the hassle. UnKibble is made by gently drying Spot & Tango’s recipes. So there are two different methods to consider.

I don’t think you’ll go wrong with Tally’s Ranch, and it’s a great choice. However, at this time, I would recommend UnKibble due to its more established business.

UnKibble

Spot and Tango are a well-established pet food company that offers a fresh frozen range and a dry food range. For this comparison article, we’re looking at UnKibble.

We’ve previously fed UnKibble to Copper and Skye with success. My Alaskan Klee Kai dogs liked all the UnKibble recipes, but their favorite was the beef and barley. I was disappointed to learn that they removed their chicken recipe from their dry food menu in 2026.

UnKibble uses a gentle air-drying process to create its dry food range, made with human-grade meat, fruit and vegetables. Like Tally’s Ranch, you won’t find any additives, fillers or nasties in their recipes.

As a dog owner, I appreciate that Spot and Tango use clear, simple labeling to avoid confusion. It’s a transparent approach that built my trust. I like the simplicity of their packaging.

UnKibble provides a custom scooper, which makes feeding time easy because it is as simple as scooping and serving direct into their bowl. I love the convenience of this.

Having reviewed over 30 dog food brands in the United States, Spot and Tango is the only brand that includes a custom scooper. They followed through on the personalization element of their business, where many other dog food companies don’t.

Did UnKibble pass the taste test? Well, I retested their food in 2026. Copper and Skye continued to enjoy their food, especially as a table topper alongside raw dog food.

My UnKibble subscription costs $164.40 per month for Copper and Skye, making their pet food service more affordable than fresh or raw dog food.

This is a $24.40 price increase over the $140 I paid in 2023 when I first ordered UnKibble.

Do you want to learn more?
You can read my UnKibble review.

Tally’s Ranch

Tally’s Ranch is a relatively new player in the dog food space, offering pet owners the opportunity to try its freeze-dried raw dog food range.

They offer two recipes: beef and chicken. Tally’s Ranch’s dry food contains 70% USDA-sourced meat, with the rest of the nuggets made from vegetables, oils and minerals.

Tally’s Ranch cooks its dishes using a freeze-drying process to preserve the nutritional goodness of its ingredients. This ensures their pet food remains shelf-stable. You won’t have to make space in your fridge or freezer!

The Farmer's Dog or Tally's Ranch?
You can read our comparison article.

While pet owners are required to complete a sign-up questionnaire, you won’t get a custom scooper. Tally’s Ranch offers a stylish golden scooper, but it isn’t tailored to your dog’s daily needs. Instead, you’ll need to follow their feeding guidelines.

Copper and Skye enjoyed eating Tally’s Ranch throughout our trial period with their freeze-dried food. Even Skye would finish all her meals. This was a good sign as she’s the pickier of my two Alaskan Klee Kai dogs.

When I did a fresh test of Tally’s Ranch in 2026, I used it as a table topper alongside their daily We Feed Raw portions. They liked eating it, perhaps because it added another texture to their bowl.

Should you pick Sundays or Tally's Ranch?
We deliver our answer here.

Tally’s Ranch is more expensive than two of the big names in the dry dog food market: Sundays For Dogs and UnKibble. But Tally’s Ranch is cheaper than some other dry food options, such as Ollie, The Pets Table and Open Farm.

I was initially sent a free bag to review in 2025. However, I’ve ordered from them twice to keep my article up to date. My initial subscription price was around $190, but I paid $219 when I ordered again in 2026.

I believe Tally’s Ranch provides good service, with tasty food that my picky eater approves of, and is worth a try if you’re interested in the freeze-dried format and its potential benefits.

Do you want to learn more about Tally's Ranch?
We took a deep dive into their food here.

UnKibble Vs Tally’s Ranch Price Comparison

Wrapping Up

We’ve reached the end of my comparison article. My recommendation would be UnKibble.

UnKibble provides a more thorough service with more recipes, a custom scooper and tailored meal plans at a competitive price.

We’ve used it on and off for three years, and my dogs have also enjoyed it whenever we’ve used it as a table topper. In 2026, UnKibble is the most affordable dog food subscription brand.

We currently use We Feed Raw.
Here's how it compares to Tally's Ranch.

However, Tally’s Ranch is worth a try if you’ve already tried UnKibble and are looking for something new. Perhaps you’ve always wanted to try raw dog food for your pup, but you don’t like the hassle. Tally’s Ranch’s freeze-dried food could be a great alternative.

While I don’t think you’ll go wrong with Tally’s Ranch, I’d give UnKibble the slight edge for its superior experience.