6 Best JustFoodForDogs Alternatives (2026): Tested On Picky Dogs

Have you been feeding your dog JustFoodForDogs but you want to make a change to a different pet food format or subscription plan? I’ve singled out six alternatives to consider having tested these options with my Alaskan Klee Kai, including my picky eater Skye.

I’ve tested over 30 different dog food brands with my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs in the search for something that my fussy eater Skye will consistently eat after years of headaches.

We’ve personally reviewed some of the leading brands across different pet food formats, including JustFoodForDogs. In fact, I first reviewed their fresh dog food back in 2019.

They offer a great range of recipes to cater to picky dogs like Skye, while they’ve got health-specific formulations if your dog has an ongoing concern that you’re looking to support.

While my dogs did enjoy their food, I felt my subscription experience lacked the customization of some of their competitors, while the price was a little steep compared to other companies.

In this JustFoodForDogs comparison review, I’ll share some options across fresh, air-dried, raw, freeze-dried, and dry dog food, while sharing budget and premium options.

Show table of contents Hide table of contents

Watch: Best JustFoodForDogs Alternatives

Best Fresh Alternative: The Farmer’s Dog

The Farmer’s Dog offers fresh dog food in the form of four recipes that you can get grain-inclusive and grain-free. At the current time, you can choose between beef, chicken, pork and turkey. They gently cook their vet-formulated food before shipping it frozen. You will need to make space in your fridge and freezer. I’ve tested it every year since 2023 and it remains one of my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs’ favorite fresh dog food options.

How does The Farmer’s Dog compare to JustFoodForDogs?

The Farmer’s Dog doesn’t offer the same variety of recipes or dog food formats as JustFoodForDogs, but they excel in other ways. You get better customization, personalization, portioning and overall convenience. The Farmer’s Dog costs $251 for Copper and Skye, which works out $61 cheaper every month when compared to my JustFoodForDogs price.

Best Raw Alternative: We Feed Raw

We Feed Raw is my top recommendation if you have a picky dog like Skye. You have the choice between frozen raw or freeze-dried raw, or you can feed both like me. They’ve got five proteins on offer within their frozen raw range. Their food completely changed Skye’s eating habit. She’s no longer fussy at mealtime and consistently enjoys eating her raw food.

How does We Feed Raw compare to JustFoodForDogs?

We Feed Raw has frozen raw and freeze-dried raw food, something which JustFoodForDogs don’t offer as part of their range. So if you’re switching from JustFoodForDogs and you’re ready to give raw feeding a try for the first time, We Feed Raw is a great choice. My subscription costs less than JustFoodForDogs at $280/month (frozen raw) and $202/month (freeze dried). We’ve had two years of consistent success feeding it to Skye.

Best Air-Dried Alternative: Sundays for Dogs

Sundays for Dogs offers a range of air-dried recipes for dogs who love a high-meat content, treat-like texture and tend to prefer dry food over fresh or raw. Sundays has three recipes: beef, chicken and turkey. They don’t include a custom scooper but their food is shelf-stable. We ordered their food for the first time in 2023 and stuck with it for almost a year before switching to raw feeding. It’s my top pick for dog owners who want to switch to air-dried.

How does Sundays compare to JustFoodForDogs?

Sundays provide air-dried food, something which JustFoodForDogs don’t have within their extensive range. If you’ve got your mind set on air dried, then Sundays can provide something JustFoodForDogs can’t. Sundays is also cheaper: we paid $218 a month for their dry dog food.

Best Fresh And Dry Alternative: The Pets Table

The Pets Table offers three pet food formats: fresh, EasyFresh and air-dried dog food. That’s a lot of options for pet owners who have a fussy eater like Skye. With different dog food formats comes flexible subscription plans, whether you want to combine fresh and air dried or EasyFresh and air dried. The Pets Table have five fresh recipes, four air-dried recipes and two EasyFresh options. If you value variety and your dog enjoys different textures in their bowl, The Pets Table is worth considering.

How does The Pets Table compare to JustFoodForDogs?

The Pets Table has plenty of choice when it comes to formats and recipes, although not quite as many as JustFoodForDogs. Where The Pets Table does a better job is with a customized subscription plan and a more affordable price. All of their formats come in cheaper than JustFoodForDogs, with their EasyFresh and air-dried plans priced around $190 for my dogs, and their fresh plan costing me around $275.

Best Affordable Alternative: UnKibble

UnKibble uses a proprietary low-temperature cooking and dehydration method called FreshDry to create their dry dog food. While that might sound like marketing speak, it’s basically dry dog food with the benefits of fresh. Their recipes are vet formulated and I appreciate the ingredient transparency with clear labeling on the front of every bag. They’ve got three recipes, with beef proving the most popular with my Alaskan Klee Kai.

How does UnKibble compare to JustFoodForDogs?

UnKibble offers great convenience and personalization compared to JustFoodForDogs, particularly their fresh dog food ranges. UnKibble created a custom scooper for Skye and Copper so I didn’t have to worry about portioning. It’s as simple as scooping the food into their bowls and serving it. UnKibble is much cheaper at $164 per month, compared to JustFoodForDogs ($312).

Best Premium Fresh Alternative: Golden Child

Golden Child is a relatively new player in the fresh dog food space but I’ve included them because Skye and Copper loved their recipes (beef and chicken). It looked more like stir-fry than dog food. They include functional drizzles (beef, chicken and peanut butter flavors) to add even more flavor and more health benefits. I was impressed by their sign-up questionnaire, which was one of the most thorough I’ve encountered.

How does Golden Child compare to JustFoodForDogs?

Golden Child offers two fresh dog food mains and three drizzles. While JustFoodForDogs have a much bigger range of dry and fresh dog food, they don’t provide functional drizzles. Copper and Skye preferred eating Golden Child over JustFoodForDog’s recipes, but their food was more expensive. I paid $348 for Golden Child, although you can get a trial box for $75.

Reasons You Might Want To Stick With JustFoodForDogs

While I’ve provided some alternatives to JustFoodForDogs that I believe are worth considering, there are also plenty of reasons to stick with your current dog food.

I love that JustFoodForDogs have so much variety within their dog food range, whether you want fresh dog food, shelf-stable dog food, targeting nutrition, toppers or supplements.

My dogs have also shown the most interest in the fresh dog food recipes, and I’ve picked up some from my local pet store in the past when we’ve run out of our regular dog food.

That’s another factor to consider before making a change. Do you want a subscription? If you’re someone who prefers the convenience of buying dog food whenever you need it at your local store, JustFoodForDogs is great.

Perhaps you don’t want to be tied into a dog food subscription and dealing with the headache of pausing or cancelling it.

They’ve got 11 stores nationwide, ranging from the East coast to the West coast. That’s something none of the other brands can claim to offer – a physical store!

JustFoodForDogs Alternatives FAQ

What is the best alternative to JustFoodForDogs?

If you don’t care about pet food format and you just want to find something your picky eater will love, I’d recommend We Feed Raw. For the closest like-for-like alternative, The Farmer’s Dog.

What is the cheapest alternative to JustFoodForDogs?

UnKibble is the cheapest alternative if you don’t care about whether you’re feeding dry over fresh because it was around $148 cheaper on a monthly basis.

Is The Farmer’s Dog better than JustFoodForDogs?

I had better success feeding The Farmer’s Dog over JustFoodForDogs to my Alaskan Klee Kai. I preferred their customization and portioning, all at a lower monthly cost.

Are there alternatives to JustFoodForDogs that don’t require freezer space?

UnKibble doesn’t require any freezer space if you’re willing to consider their dry food, while We Feed Raw provide freeze-dried raw food that is shelf stable.

Is raw dog food better than JustFoodForDogs?

My dogs preferred raw food over JustFoodForDogs, especially We Feed Raw. I’ve never seen Skye react with so much excitement and show so much consistency with dog food until We Feed Raw.

Wrapping Up

I’ve shared six alternatives to JustFoodForDogs to suit different dogs, feeding preferences and budgets.

JustFoodForDogs is still a great option if you’re happy with their fresh dog food and you’re not convinced you need to make a change.

While JustFoodForDogs has a lot of merits, especially if you’re looking for health-specific nutrition, my dogs were hit and miss with their recipes.

My overall recommendation is We Feed Raw if you’re at your wits’ end with a picky eater and you want something they’ll consistently finish.

If you prefer to stick with fresh dog food rather than changing to another pet food format, Copper and Skye have always enjoyed The Farmer’s Dog.

The best price comes with an UnKibble subscription and you’re not sacrificing on ingredient quality. In fact, they offer the best personalization and convenience.