Last Updated on December 11, 2023 by Kieran Beckles
Are you ready to give a dog food delivery company but you’re struggling to decide whether UnKibble or Ollie is a better option for your dog?
I’ve been on a journey trying to find the best human grade dog food for my Alaskan Klee Kai who are picky eaters with food allergies since moving back to California from the UK in 2023.
There’s no shortage of fresh dog food companies in the USA so it can be a little confusing and overwhelming trying to decide to the best dog food for your dog.
I’ve spent my money testing out a number of fresh dog food brands in a bid to find the healthy dog food that’s convenient and affordable to feed to Copper and Skye.
In this comparison article, I’m going to be taking a look at two of the leading dog food delivery services in the USA at the current time – UnKibble by Spot & Tango and Ollie.
I’ll be highlighting UnKibble and Ollie’s fresh recipes, how their subscription plan works, the monthly cost and give my verdict based upon feeding their dog food to Copper and Skye.
Cut To The Chase: We recommend UnKibble and you can save 50% on your first UnKibble order via this link.
What Is UnKibble?
UnKibble is a dry food range created by experienced fresh dog food company Spot & Tango.
They only use fresh, whole ingredients in their recipes such as USDA meat, fresh fruit and vegetables, as well as superfoods, to provide balanced and complete dry food for dogs.
UnKibble only use human grade ingredients in their recipes unlike traditional kibble, while you won’t find any artificial preservatives, additives, or nasties in their dry food recipes.
It’s worth noting that their fresh meals have been formulated by board certified veterinary nutritionists, ensuring their dry food caters to needs of dogs.
To get started with UnKibble, you’ll need to fill out their sign-up questionnaire to allow Spot & Tango to tailor their UnKibble recipes to meet the needs of your dog’s diet.
They’ll also created a customized scooper to ensure pet owners are feeding the right amount of UnKibble at each mealtime, whether your dog needs to gain or lose weight.
UnKibble offer four dry dog food recipes – chicken and brown rice, beef and barley, cod and salmon, and turkey and sweet potato.
Once you get your UnKibble meals, you simply need to use the scooper to feed your dog’s food before resealing the bag and popping it back in your cupboard.
Our Verdict On UnKibble
While I tend to prefer fresh dog food meals that are flash frozen for Copper and Skye, I decided to give UnKibble a try after reading that their human grade dog food is 40% cheaper than fresh frozen meals.
I was impressed by UnKibble’s limited-ingredient recipes for their fresh meals, using human grade ingredients listed in clear labels. UnKibble use human food that you or I would eat as part of our diet.
It was simple to sign up to receive their fresh dog food and I felt like their questionnaire was detailed.
When I received my first delivery of UnKibble, I was impressed with the detailed reading materials, packaging and customized scooper.
I love that I can use the scooper to place UnKibble in my dog’s bowl before resealing the bag and placing it back in the cupboard.
Even though I wasn’t fresh frozen meals, I could still spot human grade ingredients in Copper and Skye’s meals with specks of green and orange.
Copper and Skye liked UnKibble much more than most kibble brands that I’ve tried. They emptied their bowls consistently in the initial weeks.
Skye was slightly slower and less enthusiastic than Copper about UnKibble but she’s a picky eater.
UnKibble claim that their dry dog food food is 40% cheaper than fresh dog food meals. I paid $34.64 per week or $138.56 per month for their dry dog food.
What Is Ollie?
Ollie is a fresh dog food company to provide fresh recipes for dogs in the USA.
Ollie have created fresh meals using natural, human-grade ingredients to provide pet owners the opportunity to make a positive change to your dog’s diet.
To get started with Ollie, you’ll need to fill out their sign-up questionnaire to allow the dog food delivery brand to get to know your canine companion.
Ollie only use USDA-approved meat, fresh fruit and vegetables and other natural ingredients in vet-approved recipes.
At the time of writing, Ollie offer five different recipes – beef, chicken, turkey, lamb and pork. Ollie will suggest a meal plan based upon your answers to their questionnaire.
Like all dog food delivery companies, Ollie will ship your fresh meals direct to your door. Once you’ve received your fresh recipes, you’ll need to store them in the fridge or freezer.
Ollie provide pet owners with a meal container and a scooper to remove some of the faff and mess sometimes associated with feeding fresh food recipes to dogs.
It’s important to note that Ollie’s scooper isn’t customized, unlike UnKibble’s scooper that’s made to meet your dog’s specific daily potion requirements.
Our Verdict On Ollie
I’ve typically fed fresh food meals to Copper and Skye that’s human food in fresh recipes tailored to meet my Alaskan Klee Kai’s dog food.
So Ollie fit the bill in terms of the typical dog food format that I’d buy for my Klee Kai.
I found it simple to sign up to get Ollie’s dog food and as someone with picky eaters, it was brilliant to see that they offer five fresh food meals to provide good variety.
Unlike most dog food brands that I’ve reviewed, I was impressed by the fact that Ollie provide a meal container and dog food scooper to make mealtime less messy.
While I’ve fed fresh food meals to Copper and Skye for years, I don’t like having half opened meal pouches in the fridge. It can get messy. So Ollie’s meal container was much appreciated.
When I opened up Ollie’s delivery box, I felt like the meals looked more like pate than fresh meals. The meal pouches were more like a brick of dog food than fresh food.
Copper and Skye weren’t overly interested in Ollie’s meals. They showed mild interest in their fresh food but it wasn’t long before my Klee Kai started to turn their nose up at Ollie.
I believe Ollie is expensive. While they do provide premium meals, so it shouldn’t come as a surprise. Having said that, it’s still pricey compared to other pet food delivery services.
I coughed up $7.32 a day (or $219.60 a month based on 30-day month) for Ollie’s meals.
UnKibble Or Ollie: Our Pick
We’ve reached the key part of our comparison article – do we recommend UnKibble or Ollie?
Well, it probably won’t come as a surprise if you’re still reading this dog food review that our pick is UnKibble.
I love that UnKibble use human grade ingredients in recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists. So you’re getting all the benefits of a fresh food diet in a convenient dry dog food format.
UnKibble provide a custom scooper to ensure Copper and Skye are eating the right amount of dog food to meet their weight goals.
Once mealtime was over, I could pop UnKibble in the cupboard and didn’t need to make space in my fridge or freezer.
UnKibble is an affordable way to geed fresh food to dogs at an affordable price when compared to some dog food delivery companies.
Some Alaskan Klee Kai can be picky eaters but for the most part, Copper and Skye enjoyed UnKibble’s recipes. Their favourites are chicken and brown rice and beef and barley.
Where To Buy UnKibble?
UnKibble’s high quality food can only be purchased on Spot & Tango’s website. You can purchase your dog’s food via this link or the website below.
Do We Have An UnKibble Discount?
We contacted Spot & Tango to secure an exclusive coupon code or discount for our Life With Klee Kai community.
If you’re ready to give UnKibble a try, you can save 50% on your first UnKibble order via this link or the button below.
Where To Buy Ollie?
Dog owners can only purchase Ollie via their website. You won’t find their dog food at your local pet store or supermarket. To order Ollie, click this link or the button below.
Do We Have An Ollie Discount?
You can save 50% on your first Ollie order via this link or the button below.
Anything Else To Consider?
If you’re ready to make a change to your dog’s food, you should speak to you vet to learn about the potential things to consider whether you’ve got a picky eater or dog with food sensitivities.
It’s great that you want to switch from regular dog food such as wet food or kibble in favour of gently cooked fresh food.
UnKibble and Ollie have good customer service teams who can answer any questions and provide extra guidance on how to make the transition.
Spot & Tango offer a money back guarantee if your dog doesn’t like their UnKibble recipes.
Wrapping Up – Our Conclusion
We’ve reached the end of our comparison article taking a look UnKibble and Ollie.
My recommendation would be UnKibble dog food based upon their limited-ingredient recipes, customized scooper, human grade ingredients, convenient storage and price.
Most importantly, Copper and Skye enjoyed UnKibble more than Ollie.
If you’re a pet owner ready to try new dog food for your pup, UnKibble is a great starting point.
Spot & Tango provide a convenient dog food that doesn’t take up fridge or freezer space, while it doesn’t break the bank.
Kieran runs Life With Klee Kai on social media and other online platforms alongside his wife Yasmin. With over 10 years of experience as a journalist and a passionate dog owner, Kieran loves to combine his passion for pets and writing to share useful insights and product reviews to help other dog owners.