Last Updated on December 14, 2023 by Kieran Beckles
Have you been thinking about ditching traditional kibble or canned food in favour of a fresh approach to your dog’s diet – but you can’t decide between UnKibble and Open Farm Pet?
I’ve been on a journey to find the best dog food delivery companies in the USA that offer human grade dog food to promote a healthy diet for my Alaskan Klee Kai Skye and Copper as well as make life easier for dog owners like you and I.
When living in the UK, I typically fed fresh dog food meals to my Alaskan Klee Kai but since returning to the USA in 2023, I’ve been open to giving dry dog food a try considering the rising cost of fresh frozen meals.
In my search to find the best high quality dog food for Copper and Skye, I came across UnKibble by Spot & Tango and Open Farm Pet who are generally considered two of the best dog food companies in the USA at the moment.
In this comparison article, I’m going to take a look at UnKibble and Open Farm Pet, how they make their dry dog food, what recipes they’ve got on offer, how their subscription plan works and give my verdict on which is the best dog food.
With the introduction out of the way, let’s get started with these two fresh dog food brands.
Cut To The Chase: We recommend UnKibble and our Life With Klee Kai community can save 50% on your first order via this link.
Who Are UnKibble?
UnKibble is a range of dry dog food that was created by fresh dog food company Spot & Tango in 2020.
Spot & Tango had established themselves as one of the leading providers of fresh dog food meals but ventured into the realm of dry dog food to revolutionise kibble.
UnKibble only use human grade ingredients in their recipes that have formulated by veterinarian nutritionists to ensure your dog is eating a balanced and complete diet.
Each UnKibble recipe contains a limited number of fresh quality ingredients which are displayed on an easy-to-read label on the front of your dog’s meals.
You won’t find any artificial additives, artificial flavors, preservatives or nasties in UnKibble – it’s just high quality ingredients cooked at low temperatures.
To get started with UnKibbkle, dog owners will need to fill out a questionnaire to allow UnKibble to tailor their dry dog food to meet your pet’s specific needs to cater to all life stages.
Once you’ve completed their questionnaire, UnKibble will provide your pet’s unique meal plan.
At the time of writing, they’ve got four recipes – chicken and brown rice, beef and barley, cod and salmon, and turkey and sweet potato.
You’ll receive your first box with a customized scooper for your dog to ensure help with portion control as well as information on how to make a success transition to their
Our Verdict On UnKibble
We decided to give UnKibble a try based upon the good reviews of their dry dog food and the promise that it would be more affordable than the fresh dog food meals that we’d been feeding to our Klee Kai.
Having previously fed dry dog food to Copper and Skye with limited success, I was unsure how successful UnKibble would be because Klee Kai can be picky eaters with some digestive health issues.
When I got their dry dog food, I was impressed by the clear labelling on the front of UnKibble’s bag. Like most pet parents, I want to know my dogs are eating ingredients that I’d eat.
When I took a peak inside the bag, I was struck by the fact that UnKibble doesn’t look like traditional dry food that you find at the local pet store or supermarket.
I could spot colors of human grade ingredients in UnKibble such as green for peas and orange for carrots. Most dry dog food options are just dark brown pellets – but not with UnKibble.
Copper and Skye did enjoy UnKibble and it was a case of mealtime excitement and empty bowls.
Of the four recipes, my Klee Kai enjoyed Chicken and Brown Rice alongside Beef and Barley but they weren’t particularly enthusiastic about the other two recipes.
From a dog owner’s perspective, I loved the customized scooper that equated to pre portioned meals, as well as the ability to store their dry dog food in the cupboard rather than needing space in my fridge or freezer.
Based upon the answers I gave in Spot & Tango’s sign-up questionnaire, my meal plan cost $34.64 per week or $138.56 per month. This is substantially cheaper than most fresh dog food brands that I’ve reviewed.
Who Are Open Farm Pet?
Open Farm Pet are a versatile dog food company who offer a wide range of fresh dog food options to pet parents looking to make a change to their dog’s diet.
For the purposes of this comparison article, I’m going to be taking a look at their dry dog food options.
Open Farm offer a lot of different dry foods for dogs. You can avail of grain, grain-free, raw mix and ancient grains if you want to try something a little different.
Open Farm explain online that their human grade dog food is nutrient dense and uses non-GMO fruit and vegetables.
They responsible source all the human grade ingredients in their dog food, such as grass fed beef from family farms in the USA. You can actual track each ingredient from the source to your dog’s bowl.
You’ll find that they offer most protein sources in fresh food meals, whether you want a chicken recipe, turkey recipe or wild caught salmon recipe.
Unfortunately Open Farm don’t offer the ability to customize your dog’s meals with regards to a sign-up questionnaire like UnKibble.
You’ll have to closely follow their feeding guidelines to make sure that you feed the right amount to your dog because overfeeding wouldn’t be good for your dog’s health.
Our Verdict On Open Farm Pet
As a dog owner who tries to their bit for the environment and reduce my carbon footprint, I wanted to give Open Farm a try because I love their eco-friendly and sustainable approach to their dog food business.
There’s little doubt that Open Farm have created a range of recipes that they hope can benefit your dog’s overall health by creating fresh food that has a great nutrient content.
Unfortunately, Copper and Skye didn’t really take to Open Farm’s meals despite numerous attempts to get my Klee Kai to eat their food.
As I mentioned earlier in this article, my Klee Kai can be fussy eaters with their food and I tried feeding Open Farm but their meals weren’t a hit.
While Copper was a more willing participant when it came to eating their fresh meals, I struggled to get Skye to have more than a few mouthfuls.
Every dog is different and your pup may love eating their recipes. They’re healthy and affordable.
While Open Farm’s dry food wasn’t a hit, Copper and Skye did like their Gently Cooked fresh food range – but that’s their fresh frozen meals so not relevant to this particular comparison piece.
UnKibble Or Open Farm Pet: Who Do We Recommend?
We’ve reached the key part of this comparison dog food review – who do we recommend?
Well, if I had to decide between UnKibble or Open Farm for my Alaskan Klee Kai, I’d go for UnKibble.
I really liked that UnKibble use limited ingredient recipes containing fresh foods that pet owners will recognise.
They offer a subscription service so irrespective of your dog’s age, whether you’ve got puppies, adult dogs or senior dogs, UnKibble has you and your furry friend covered.
UnKibble’s dry dog food looked fresher and smelt fresher, and my Alaskan Klee Kai did prefer their fresh meals when comparing these two dry dog foods.
I appreciated the fact that UnKibble provided a customized scooper to make it easy for dog owners to get the portions right and you simply have to pour their human grade dry food into your dog’s bowl.
Of these two dog food brands, I felt UnKibble offered a more personal touch.
While you won’t go wrong with either of these dog food delivery companies, I’d recommend UnKibble.
Where To Buy UnKibble?
You can only buy Spot & Tango’s dry food range UnKibble direct from their website. To get started, you can click this link or hit the button below.
Do We Have An UnKibble Discount?
If you’re interested in signing up to this dog food delivery company, we’ve got a special offer for pet parents.
You can save 50% on your first order of UnKibble pet food when you click this link or hit the button below.
Your 50% discount on UnKibble’s dry food will be automatically applied at the checkout.
Where To Buy Open Farm Pet?
If you want to change your pet food and you’ve decided Open Farm represents the best choice for you and your canine companion, you can browse their range of fresh dog foods on their website.
Do We Have An Open Farm Pet Discount?
At the time of writing, we don’t have an exclusive saving on Open Farm’s dry food or fresh food. We’ll keep this comparison review regularly updated in the event that we do manage to get our hands on discount for our community.
Anything Else To Consider?
If you’re thinking about making a change to your dog’s food, you should speak to your vet before you go ahead and introduce new pet food.
It’s not a good idea to to change your dog food without slowly transitioning your pet onto their new food, whether it’s dry food or fresh food.
Your vet can offer guidance on how to successfully make the change to your pet food, or whether your dog may have any food allergies to consider before switching up their dog food.
As with most respectable fresh food brands, Spot & Tango and Open Farm have excellent customer service teams to answer questions your may have about their dog food.
We’ve reached the end of our comparison feature taking a look at UnKibble and Open Farm.
Having considered these two dog food companies and testing their fresh food on my Klee Kai, my recommendation would be UnKibble.
My Alaskan Klee Kai loved their dry food, especially the chicken and brown rice recipe. While they don’t usually like dry food, Copper and Skye were happy to eat UnKibble apart from the fish and turkey recipe.
It’s clear that UnKibble care about dog nutrition from the human grade ingredients in their vet-formulated recipes, while they offer a happy pup guarantee in the event your dog doesn’t like their dry food.
Having reviewed many dry dog food brands since returning to the USA for our Life With Klee Kai family, I’d consider UnKibble to be one of the best options alongside this air dried dog food company.
Kieran runs Life With Klee Kai on social media and other online platforms alongside his wife Yasmin. With over 10 years of experience as a journalist and a passionate dog owner, Kieran loves to combine his passion for pets and writing to share useful insights and product reviews to help other dog owners.