Butternut Box Vs Forthglade: What’s The Difference?

Last Updated on July 3, 2024 by Kieran Beckles

Are you thinking about switching to Butternut Box or Forthglade, but you’re not sure which of the two brands would be the best fit for your pup?

We’ve previously fed both Butternut Box and Forthglade to Copper and Skye, so we’re well-positioned to discuss the differences and similarities between these two brands.

It can be a confusing and overwhelming experience trying to decide what’s the right dog food for your dog because there are so many options in the UK at the moment.

Whether you want fresh dog food, customized kibble, high-quality wet food, air-dried dog food, freeze-dried dog food, raw dog food or grain-free dog food.

For this article, we’re going to take a look at the difference between Butternut Box and Forthglade based on our experience and our research.

(Cut to the chase: We recommend Butternut Box and you can save 50% off your first box and 50% off your second box by clicking here).

Butternut Box Vs Forthglade: Our Verdict

Let’s cut to the chase if you’re ready to sign up for a new dog food subscription and you want to decide between Butternut Box and Forthglade, here’s my pick.

We consider Butternut Box to be a superior option to Forthglade. Having tried both dog food brands with my Alaskan Klee Kai, Butternut Box was the clear winner.

I found that Copper and Skye loved their fresh meals. I had a great range of recipes to choose from. If Skye showed the slightest hint of fussiness, it was great to have the ability to whip out a Wham Bam Lamb or You’ve Got Game to offer her a more decadent option than low-fat Gobble Gobble Turkey.

They offer a customized service unlilke Forthglade. Butternut Box take the time to get to know your dog and put together a meal plan to take care of their needs and weight goals.

While Butternut Box is customized to meet Copper and Skye’s needs, I consider it to be an affordable option that doesn’t cost more than a cup of coffee a day. By paying that price, I have confidence that Copper and Skye are eating a balanced and complete diet that’s fresh, vet approved and keeps fussiness and sensitive tummies at bay.

If you’ve got a fussy eater or a dog with a sensitive tummy like me, you likely won’t mind paying a bit extra if your dog consistently eats at mealtime.

Butternut Box

Butternut Box is a fresh dog food company who have been putting the food back into dog food since 2016. Since launching their business, they’ve already fed an incredible 100,000 dogs in the UK.

To start your Butternut Box journey, you’ll need to take their sign-up questionnaire so they can get some key information about your four-legged friend. This includes age, size, weight, breed, daily exercise, eating habits and health conditions.

Once Butternut Box has this information, they’ll put together a suggested meal plan. While you can go with their recipe suggestions, you’re able to alter your dog’s meals if you believe they’ll enjoy a particular recipe or you think they’d like a varied selection.

Butternut Box use high-quality ingredients in their recipes. They’re comprised of 60% meat and 40% fruit/vegetables. At the time of writing, Butternut Box have an incredible 12 recipes so if you’ve got a fussy eater like Skye, you won’t be short on options.

We’ve been feeding predominantly Butternut Box for the past five years since we moved back to the UK from the USA. Initially when we returned to the UK, we struggled to find a dog food brand that agreed with Skye’s sensitive tummy.

Fortunately, we eventually came across Butternut Box – and we haven’t looked back since. Skye hasn’t been to the vet since 2019 – that’s five years without tummy problems. Skye is obsessed with Butternut Box’s meals, especially Pork This Way, Wham Bam Lamb, Duo of Duck & Chicken, and You’ve Got Game.

Copper is food motivated but he is equally as passionate about his Butternut Box meals. Seeing as he’s very food motivated, we try to give him low-fat meals such as Chicken You Out and Gobble Gobble Turkey.

At the time of writing, we’ve been paying for our Butternut Box meals. It costs between £70 and £80 a month for both Copper and Skye depending on the recipes we include in their meal plan. You’re able to adjust the monthly cost by selecting the recipes that don’t have a surge charge.

Copper and Skye wolf down their respective meals before switching bowls and making sure there’s no scraps left behind. Even fussy Skye! This has never happened with any other dog food brand that we’ve tried.

I appreciate that Butternut Box has an eco-friendly approach to their business, which allows me to feed fresh meals to my Klee Kai, but I feel good that I’m doing my part for the environment, too.

Forthglade

Forthglade is a dog food company with a lot of experience. They’ve been in operation since 1971 – so that’s over 50 years of feeding British dogs. They’ve got a range of different pet food formats on offer, from grain-free cold-pressed natural dry dog food and complete and complementary wet dog food.

The grain-free, cold-pressed dry food is created using using natural ingredients and added vitamins and minerals. It’s cold-pressed to retain the natural flavour of the food. Forthglade have two dry food recipes on offer – chicken and duck. Alternatively, you could opt for their wet dog food.

Forthglade’s website explains that their complete and complimentary wet food has been designed for dogs who have sensitive tummies. It’s made using natural ingredients and includes minerals and vitamins. They’ve got more recipes on offer within their wet food range – 75% salmon, lamb, duck, beef or turkey.

Forthglade offers their grain-free, cold-pressed dry food starting at 1kg (£8.79) to 18kg (£107.99). Their wet food started at £22.25 for 12 trays (which equates to £1.24 a tray).

We gave Copper and Skye some Forthglade to try, and the results were mixed. Copper was content to much on his Forthglade meal – we bought the grain-free, cold-pressed dry food and added some of their wet food as a tasty topper.

He’s not so fussy when it comes to his meals, so I wasn’t surprised that Copper didn’t hesitate to give it a try. However, Skye was rather more cautious. While she did try some, Skye left over half of her food in her bowl (much to Copper’s delight). We’re aware that every dog is different, and this is just my experience.

While Skye wasn’t super motivated to eat Forthglade’s food, I’m sure lots of dogs will love their meals. As a brand, I had peace of mind that they’re a trusted dog food supplier, and I like that they make a contribution to the National Trust for every meal purchased.

Where To Buy Butternut Box?

If you’d like to give Butternut Box a try, we’ve got an exclusive discount for our readers and followers.

You can get 50% off your first box and 50% off your second box when you click this link.

Wrapping Up

We’ve reached the end of our article on Butternut Box vs Forthglade.

While I think you can’t go wrong with Butternut Box or Forthglade, my personal preference would be Butternut Box.

I’ve seen the benefits of feeding Butternut Box to my two Klee Kai – they’re happy, energetic and healthy eating their fresh meals.

Having said that, Forthglade is still a great option, so if you decide to go with this experienced pet food company, you won’t go wrong.