Sundays vs Badlands Ranch Dog Food (2026): Which Is Better?
Key points
- Best for: Sundays, based on price, personalization, and Copper and Skye’s preference.
- Best for picky eaters: Sundays, especially beef and chicken recipes.
- Best for personalization: Sundays, because you get a sign-up questionnaire and get a custom meal plan.
- Best price: Sundays cost me around $218 a month, compared with $287.55 for Badlands Ranch.
- Biggest Sundays advantage: Best overall value and my dogs preferred it.
- Biggest Badlands Ranch advantage: You don’t need a subscription plan, recipe variety.
Are you ready to switch to air-dried dog food, but you can’t decide between Sundays For Dogs and Badlands Ranch?
Quick verdict
Sundays is my pick over Badlands Ranch. Copper and Skye were happy to eat both brands, but Sundays was their favorite. We consistently fed it as their main meal for over a year, and we continue to use it as a topper. I preferred their personalization and overall value. Sundays cost me about $70 less a month. Badlands Ranch is good if you want more flexibility and recipe variety, Sundays is my recommendation.
I’ve been feeding air-dried dog food to my Alaskan Klee Kai Copper and Skye, ditching store-bought kibble in favor of a complete and balanced diet for my mini huskies.
There’s no shortage of potential air-dried dog food to try alongside other healthy pet food formats, such as fresh dog food meals, freeze-dried dog food, and raw dog food.
Trying to figure out the best option for my Klee Kai was overwhelming, and I’ve reviewed over 30 different dog food brands to find the best food for my dogs.
We initially tested Sundays and Badlands Ranch in 2023, but we’ve placed subsequent orders in the past three years as these brands have improved and expanded into 2026.
In fact, we’re currently feeding one of these brands based on our success with their air-dried dog food. Copper and Skye continue to love Sundays For Dogs.
Show table of contents Hide table of contents
Watch: Sundays vs Badlands Ranch Compared
Sundays For Dogs Vs Badlands Ranch: Our Verdict
Sundays would be my pick based on the overall value provided by their dog food subscription service and my Klee Kai’s reaction to their food.
Sundays provided me with a custom meal plan for Copper and Skye tailored to their specific needs: Copper needs to lose weight, and Skye needs to maintain weight.
I believe Sundays offers better value: I paid $218 a month for Copper and Skye’s food, but Badlands Ranch cost $287.55 a month. That’s a monthly saving of $69.55.
Do you want to know your Sundays price?
You can read our price breakdown here.
I felt like Sundays provided a more complete service, given the packaging and level of detail in the information provided in my first delivery. My dogs received a custom meal plan.
In terms of Copper and Skye’s verdict, it was close. They really enjoyed both Sundays and Badlands Ranch. I didn’t notice much difference in mealtime excitement.
Having said that, I felt Sundays’ beef recipe did appear to be their overall favorite. My Klee Kai dogs were quicker to gobble down their Sundays’ dog food.
So, based on price, customization, and mealtime excitement, my pick would be Sundays.
How We Tested These Dog Foods
It was easier to get started with Sundays than with Badlands Ranch because of the website layout and sign-up process.
I completed Sundays questionnaire before receiving my custom meal plan and subscription price.
However, I had to figure out how many Badlands Ranch I required by consulting the feeding guidelines and doing some maths to order sufficient bags.
Sundays offers a more seamless customer experience when purchasing from their website.
We fed Copper and Skye their Sundays and Badlands Ranch food over the course of a month to properly test these brands.
Neither Sundays nor Badlands Ranch provided a custom scooper, so I had to use a kitchen utensil to get their portions right.
There was little difference in the taste test.
My Alaskan Klee Kai dogs enjoyed both air-dried brands. I believe the treat-like texture and high meat content played a big part.
We’ve continued to feed Sundays since our first review of their pet food in 2023.
While we didn’t ultimately stick with Badlands Ranch, we have placed subsequent orders to keep this review up to date.
Badlands Ranch has also added freeze-dried nuggets to their recipe range.
Sundays For Dogs
Sundays For Dogs uses an air-drying process to gently dry their human-grade dog food, preserving nutritional integrity and locking in flavor.
Created by vets, it’s no surprise that Sundays For Dogs only uses natural ingredients in its recipes. You won’t find any additives or preservatives in their dehydrated dog food.
Sundays tailors your dog’s meals based on the details you provide in their sign-up questionnaire. I shared details about Copper and Skye, including their ages, breeds, activity levels, diets, and any health issues.
Sundays offers beef, chicken and turkey recipes, which is a good selection for dog owners with fussy eaters like my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs.
I was worried they wouldn’t enjoy an air-dried dog food diet, since they’ve shown muted interest in traditional kibble. But I decided to give Sundays a try.
Copper and Skye loved their air-dried dog food meals (much to my surprise), and we’ve continued to feed Sundays to my Klee Kai dogs since 2023.
Sundays’ air-dried food has a treat-like texture and 90% meat content, which I think helped to convince my picky eater, Skye, to try it initially.
Copper and Skye preferred the beef and chicken recipes, but the turkey recipe wasn’t as popular with my Klee Kai. So, if you’re ready to sign up, maybe start with beef or chicken!
Badlands Ranch
Badlands Ranch offers Superfood Complete recipes to challenge the likes of Sundays and other dog food brands. It’s the creation of actress Katherine Heigl.
Badlands Ranch initially offered air-dried dog food when they launched before adding Superfood Nuggets to its range in 2025.
Unlike traditional cooking methods for dry dog food, such as kibble, Badlands Ranch dog food isn’t cooked at harsh, high temperatures.
As you’d expect from a dog food brand with a range called Superfood Complete, Badlands Ranch has created its recipes using premium, nutritious meat and healthy fruit and vegetables. You won’t find any meat meal, byproducts, or preservatives in their air-dried food.
Badlands Ranch doesn’t require pet parents to fill out a sign-up questionnaire, so dog owners should carefully follow the air-dried dog food brand’s feeding guidelines.
I was pretty confident that Copper and Skye would enjoy Badlands Ranch, considering its treat-like texture is similar to Sundays For Dogs, just a bit chunkier.
Copper and Skye were happy to eat Badlands Ranch dog food without any hesitation. My fussy eaters particularly enjoyed the beef recipe.
I did find that the Badlands Ranch dog food bags arrived squished. It may be a small detail, but the bag didn’t hold its shape, so I had to lay it flat in the cupboard.
As of 2026, my Badlands Ranch price increased to $287.55. This is expensive when you consider Sundays cost $218. I’d expect to pay that much for fresh or raw dog food.
Who Should Pick Which Brand?
Sundays For Dogs best for
- Dog owners who want a custom meal plan
- Dogs who love a treat-like texture
- Picky eaters, like my Alaskan Klee Kai Skye
- Pet parents who want a smooth ordering process
- Overall subscription value
Badlands Ranch best for
- Picking up your dog’s food at the pet store
- Dog owners who like feeding superfoods
- Bigger budgets
- Pet owners who don’t want a subscription
Sundays For Dogs Vs Badlands Ranch FAQ
I would recommend Sundays ahead of Badlands Ranch based on my experience testing these two dog food brands. Sundays offered a custom meal plan, which was a hit with my Alaskan Klee Kai, and all at an affordable price.
Badlands Ranch is comparable because it offers air-dried dog food with a high meat content, like Sundays.
Sundays is cheaper than Badlands Ranch. I paid $218 for Sundays and $287.55 for Badlands Ranch. Sundays was about $69 cheaper than Badlands Ranch, which equated to a yearly saving of $834.60.
Sundays For Dogs and Badlands Ranch both follow AAFCO guidelines in making their air-dried dog food. However, neither dog food brand meets the WSAVA protocol.
I’m not a vet or pet nutritionist, but I can share my experience feeding Sundays and Badlands Ranch to Skye, who is my picky Alaskan Klee Kai with a sensitive tummy. We had a good experience feeding these brands to Skye and didn’t experience any digestive issues.
Alternatives You Should Consider
If you’re not convinced by Sundays For Dogs or Badlands Ranch, we do have some other options that you could consider.
UnKibble is the most competitively priced of all the dry dog food brands that I’ve reviewed on the website.
We paid $164 for their human-grade dry dog food, which is $20 cheaper than Sundays and $123.55 cheaper than Badlands Ranch.
I’ve reviewed over 30 dog food brands, and my Klee Kai has a clear favorite: We Feed Raw.
They offer raw and freeze-dried dog food to cater to pet owners’ different preferences. We Feed Raw transformed my picky eater, Skye, into a food-motivated Klee Kai!
Finally, A Pup Above is another great choice. My Alaskan Klee Kai dogs enjoyed their baked recipes, which contain bone broth!
You can pick their fresh food or baked recipes but I’d recommend the dry dog food format for sheer convenience!
Finishing Up
We’ve reached the end of our Sundays For Dogs or Badlands Ranch comparison article.
While you may have read some dog food reviews for these brands, I’ve purchased and tested these air-dried dog foods on my Alaskan Klee Kai.
Both brands performed well with Skye and Copper, but Sundays was the clear winner for better value, more personalized experience, and satisfying my dogs.
Sundays For Dogs would be my top pick for dog owners wanting to try air-dried food.
Having said that, if you want to give air-dried dog food a go, I don’t think you’ll go too far wrong with either of these two dog food brands.