Last Updated on February 23, 2024 by Kieran Beckles
Are you ready to ditch regular pet food in favour of a fresh approach but you can’t decide between Sundays For Dogs air dried dog food and We Feed Raw dog food?
There’s so many different pet food formats so it can be difficult for pet owners to decide which human grade dog food to feed their pet if they’re ready to ditch traditional kibble or canned dog food in favor of fresh dog food.
With a picky eater and a slightly overweight dog, we needed to find new dog food for Copper and Skye after we returned to the USA from the UK in 2023 seeing as their favourite UK fresh food brand didn’t operate stateside.
Having tried and tests some of the best human grade dog food companies, we decided to give Sundays dog food and a We Feed Raw diet a try to see how our Alaskan Klee Kai fared eating air dried food and raw dog food.
We signed up to Sundays For Dogs and We Feed Raw using our money in order to give our honest feedback on how found introducing these two human grade diets to each dog’s diet and the impact on each dog’s health.
In this comparison article, we’re going to share our insights in Sundays’ food and We Feed Raw dog food diet, explaining how these two pet food formats work, our experience feeding dry dog food and raw food to Copper and Skye before giving our verdict on the best dog food.
Who Is We Feed Raw?
We Feed Raw is one of the leading raw dog food companies in the USA, providing dog owners with the chance to try a raw food diet without some of the hassle associated with raw feeding.
They only use USDA raw meats such as USDA beef (like beef bone, beef liver, beef heart and more) in the recipes, ensuring pets are eating human grade ingredients in transparent recipes.
You can feel confident that your dog is eating natural ingredients that’s good for your dog’s digestive system, while they don’t use any artificial colors, additives or preservatives.
We Feed Raw dog food is formulated by a PhD animal nutritionist and meets or exceeds the standards set out by the AAFCO nutrition standards. So you can have peace of mind knowing experts have created your dog’s raw food diet.
To get started, pet parents will need to complete We Feed Raw’s questionnaire to get a custom raw diet for your furry friend. You’ll be asked questions like your dog’s age, dog’s breed, dog’s weight, dog’s diet and much more to allow the raw food brand to tailor their meals accordingly.
We Feed Raw offer a beef recipe, chicken recipe, duck recipe, lamb recipe, turkey recipe and venison recipe. There’s a lot of raw meat options for dog parents who like to vary their dog’s food.
Once pet parents have finished the ordering process, We Feed Raw offer free cold shipping and your raw dog food will arrive frozen and ready to store in the freezer apart from a few meal pouches that the pet owner will need to thaw before serving.
Our Verdict On We Feed Raw
While living in the UK, we tended to avoid raw dog food because of the stereotype raw feeding is hassle. However, we decided to sign up to We Feed Raw after reading rave reviews from picky eaters.
Once we provided key details about Copper and Skye, we received our first box of raw dog food. I found it easy to stack the meal pouches in my freezer thanks to the square shape. I kept a few raw food meals in the fridge to defrost before cutting the meal packet open and pouring into each dog’s bowl. It was easy to serve and mess free.
Skye is a fussy eater with food sensitivities but I was blown away by how much she enjoyed her raw diet. She consistently showed mealtime excitement unlike any other dog food brand we’ve previously given her.
Our female Alaskan Klee Kai would stalk me every time I went near the freezer, lick her bowl clean, ensure Copper couldn’t muscle his way to her bowl. We Feed Raw transformed the behavior of our fussy eater.
We saw some health benefits after a few months – too. Copper and Skye had firmer stools, improved digestion, and healthier skin. Of course, both Alaskan Klee Kai dogs continued to show mealtime excitement.
From a dog owner’s perspective, I found We Feed Raw’s subscription service to be impressive overall. Their sign up questionnaire was easy to use, deliveries arrived on time and always frozen, and the meals were easy to feed.
I’d like to see We Feed Raw introduce a custom scooper or a pre portion guideline on the meal packets, but I considered We Feed Raw to be great value and worth the cost considering the impact on my fussy eater.
Who Is Sundays For Dogs?
Sundays For Dogs have created a range of air dried dog food for any pet parent who wants to introduce fresh dog food but without the hassle of having to deal with fresh meals or raw meals requiring freezer space.
Sundays is dry food but much healthier than traditional kibble. Sundays For Dogs use USDA meat alongside fresh ingredients such as tart cherries, shiitake mushrooms, sunflower oil, wild salmon oil, chicory root and more.
They use transparent ingredients labels on each air dried box so you can see the real food in your dog’s beef recipe, chicken recipe and turkey recipe. Sundays is created by vets and formulated by vets, ensuring its balanced and complete.
Unlike dry kibble cooked at extreme heat, Sundays use a gently air dried method to lock in all the natural flavor and nutrients. You won’t find any additives, nasties or preservatives in their air dried dog food.
To get started with Sundays dog food, you’ll need to fill out their sign up questionnaire to allow Sundays to understand your dog’s specific needs and tailor their recipes accordingly. They offer three recipes – beef, chicken and turkey.
Once you’ve received your first box, you can pour directly into your dog’s bowl and follow the provided feeding guidelines to get the portions correct. When you’re done, you simply reseal the bag seeing as it’s shelf stable food that lasts up to 6 to 7 weeks once opened.
Our Verdict On Sundays For Dogs
Having seen some Sundays For Dogs reviews online, I decided to place an order to see how Copper and Skye would like their air dried dog food.
Sundays appealed to me thanks to their convenient and hassle free nature of air dried food – you don’t need freezer space, no mess at mealtime and its cheaper than fresh food.
When I got my hands on our first order, I liked Sundays have a transparent approach to their service. They use clear and concise labelling and explanations, giving us peace of mind about the ingredients in their dog food and how their air dried food is made.
Copper and Skye really enjoyed the treat-like texture of Sundays – in fact, we used it as treats throughout the day, especially for scent work games.
We found our Alaskan Klee Kai loved the beef and chicken recipe but the turkey recipe was hit and miss. Skye showed mealtime excitement which I think was in part thanks to the protein – 90% meat content.
Having review a lot of dog food brands in the USA since returning to California, Sundays’ dog food is one of the most affordable and most convenient options that we’ve tried.
Sundays For Dogs Vs We Feed Raw: Price Breakdown
When trying to decide between two dog food brands, price is a big factor.
So let’s take a look at a price breakdown for Sundays and We Feed Raw so you can see how much we pay for their dog food.
As you’ll likely know by now, I’ve got two 11lb Alaskan Klee Kai dogs called Copper and Skye. They’re relatively small dogs of a similar age, similar daily exercise requirements and similar dietary requirements.
Based upon my experience with Sundays Food For Dogs, I can expect to pay $138 a month. When signing up my Alaskan Klee Kai to receive their excellent food, I had to pay $193 a month.
That’s a difference of $65 a month or $760 over the course of a year!
Sundays For Dogs Vs We Feed Raw: Our Verdict
Now that we’ve shared our experiences with Sundays and We Feed Raw, who do we recommend?
Well, it’s a tough one because it comes down to whether you prefer to feed air dried dog food or raw dog food. It’s an individual decision based upon the circumstances of every pet owner.
We were impressed with both dog food brands. We would consider We Feed Raw to be the best raw dog food we’ve tested and Sundays to be the best air dried pet food we’ve reviewed.
If you’re looking to upgrade on kibble or canned food to something fresher, you won’t go wrong with either Sundays or We Feed Raw. Their food has a high nutritional value, perfect for picky eaters and competitively priced when compared to their rivals within their particular pet food formats.
We made the decision to feed a combination of We Feed Raw and Sundays to Copper and Skye – because we liked having different textures in their meals.
(Note: we worked with our vet to make sure we weren’t overfeeding or underfeeding)
Having experienced the stress of trying to encourage a fussy eater to finish their meals, I would say if you do have a picky pup, I’d start by trying We Feed Raw because Skye’s reaction to their raw dog food blew us away. It was like she was ravenous!
Once you’ve given We Feed Raw a try, you can get a feel for what it’s like feeding raw dog food, freezing your raw meat pouches, thawing them at mealtime and how your dog enjoys eating raw meat.
If you’d prefer less dog food in your freezer or you believe it’s just too much hassle, you could switch to Sundays whose air dried recipes don’t require freezer space and stay fresh up to seven weeks.
Whether you ditch the kibble or canned food in favour of Sundays or We Feed Raw, you’re introducing healthy dog food and will hopefully experience the benefits of feeding human grade dog food like we have.
Where To Buy We Feed Raw?
If you’re ready to give raw dog food a go, you can start your We Feed Raw subscription by heading to their website or using the button below.
Do We Have Discount For We Feed Raw?
We reached out to We Feed Raw and secured a 25% discount for our Life With Klee Kai community. To get started with their raw dog food, just visit their website here or use the button below and the 25% discount will automatically be applied.
Where To Buy Sundays?
Sundays require dog owners to complete a sign up questionnaire so you’ll need to visit their website here or use the button below to get some Sundays’ dog food.
Do We Have Discount For Sundays?
We contacted Sundays and managed to secure an exclusive 50% discount off their dog food if you’re ready to sign up. All you need to do is visit their website or hit the button below and the 50% discount will automatically be applied at checkout.
Wrapping Up
So there we have it, we’ve reached the end of our Sundays and We Feed Raw comparison dog food article.
We love these two dog food brands and struggled to separate them. As a result, we ended up ordering air dried pet food and raw dog food for our Alaskan Klee Kai.
We’re continuing to pay for subscriptions to these two dog food companies, which is the best possible review of their services.
If you’re ready to bin the dry pet food or wet food from the pet store in favour of a healthy approach, our dogs love Sundays and We Feed Raw so we suspect your pet might enjoy their food too, whether you opt for air dried or raw dog food.
Kieran runs Life With Klee Kai on social media and other online platforms alongside his wife Yasmin. With over 10 years of experience as a journalist and a passionate dog owner, Kieran loves to combine his passion for pets and writing to share useful insights and product reviews to help other dog owners.