Sundays Vs The Farmer’s Dog (2026): Which Dog Food Is Better?
Key points
- Our pick: The Farmer’s Dog if you want fresh food, Sundays if you want a shelf-stabe alternative.
- Best for picky eaters: Sundays, based on Copper and Skye’s long-term reaction to its jerky-like texture.
- Best fresh food: The Farmer’s Dog, based on personalization, portioning, and Copper and Skye’s reaction.
- Best for convenience: Sundays, because it doesn’t require fridge or freezer space.
- Best for personalization: The Farmer’s Dog, because Copper and Skye’s meals were individually labeled, with each meal packet having their own portion guideline.
- Best for price: Sundays costs me around $218 a month, compared with around $251 for The Farmer’s Dog.
- Biggest Sundays advantage: Shelf-stable convenience and picky-eater appeal.
- Biggest The Farmer’s Dog advantage: Fresh meals with stronger personalization and portioning.
Are you considering switching from The Farmer’s Dog to Sundays For Dogs and want to know the difference between the two dog food delivery services?
Quick verdict
I’d choose between Sundays and The Farmer’s Dog based on the type of food you want to feed. If you’re happy to deal with some of the inconveniences of fresh dog food such as requiring fridge and freezer space and slightly higher cost, The Farmer’s Dog is great. My dogs loved its fresh recipes. But if you want shelf-stable dog food at a lower price, Sundays would be my pick. Skye and Copper liked the higher-meat content and jerky-like texture.
These pet food brands have become hugely popular in the USA in recent years, thanks to their human-grade dog food tailored to your dog’s needs, delivered directly to your doorstep.
If you’re familiar with Copper and Skye, you’ll know that they can be picky sometimes with sensitive tummies – that’s why we try to feed human-grade dog food.
We’ve seen the benefits of feeding high-quality dog food formulated by veterinary nutritionists that uses human-grade ingredients such as USDA-certified meat, fresh fruits and vegetables, and superfoods.
I’ll be taking a close look at Sundays and The Farmer’s Dog, starting by sharing our verdict on the best dog food delivery service. You can watch my comparison video below if you prefer.
Show table of contents Hide table of contents
Watch: Sundays vs The Farmer’s Dog Comparison Review In Action
Sundays For Dogs Or The Farmer’s Dog: Our Pick
If you’ve landed on this comparison article and you want to cut straight to the answer rather than reading about Sundays and The Farmer’s Dog in more detail, we’ll start by sharing our recommendation.
If I were to sign up permanently to one of these brands, it would be Sundays For Dogs.
I like that Copper and Skye can enjoy all the benefits of fresh food without the hassle of making space in my fridge and freezer, and without any messing around with meal packets and utensils.
Sundays For Dogs has a higher protein content in their air-dried dog food than a lot of fresh food meals.
For example, Sundays’ beef recipe contains 90% protein, but The Farmer’s Dog’s beef recipe has just 41%. So that’s a big difference!
There’s also the price to consider when weighing up which of these two well-established brands offers the best dog food delivery service.
Sundays For Dogs would cost me $218 a month, but The Farmer’s Dog would set me back $251.04 a month. Over the course of the year, that’s $396.48 saving!
Who Are Sundays For Dogs?
Sundays For Dogs is one of the leading providers of dry dog food in the USA. While they provide American pet owners with the opportunity to feed dry food, Sundays’ dog food is different from traditional kibble or canned food that you may find at your local supermarket.
Sundays only use human-grade ingredients in their recipes that are formulated by veterinary nutritionists – giving you peace of mind your pet is eating healthy dog food.
Unlike a lot of fresh dog food brands that use high-quality ingredients in their recipes, Sundays’ dog food has a high protein content – 90% to be precise. The other 10% is made up of superfoods to promote a healthy lifestyle for dogs of all ages.
Sundays has created three recipes to cater to pet owners who want to feed human-grade dog food: Beef, Chicken and Turkey. It’s a decent range for dog owners with a picky eater like me.
To get started with Sundays, you’ll need to fill out their sign-up questionnaire before Sundays creates a custom meal plan and shares the monthly cost of their dog food delivery service.
Sundays’ dog food is convenient because it’s shelf-stable and can be stored in your cupboard rather than taking up space in the fridge or freezer. Once you’ve fed your dog, you reseal the bag and put it away.
Not only does Sundays offer one of the highest protein contents of all the fresh dog food that we’ve reviewed, but Sundays’ dog food is 36% cheaper than fresh dog food delivery companies.
I was hesitant to feed air-dried dog food to Copper and Skye when we first moved back to California because they’d been eating fresh dog food in the UK. However, I was encouraged by the stellar reviews of Sundays’ food and how they catered to dogs with food allergies like Copper and picky eaters like Skye.
It was relatively simple to get started with their dog food delivery service – their sign-up questionnaire is straightforward, and you can breeze through it in minutes.
In the past, Skye has been fussy with traditional kibble or other dry dog food – but she loved Sundays! Copper was also a fan, but that was less of a surprise because he’s more food-motivated.
From a dog owner’s perspective, I liked that Sundays For Dogs could be stored in the cupboard after I’d finished feeding Copper and Skye. As someone used to fresh pet food, I was glad to free up space in the fridge and freezer for our food rather than for fresh dog food. There was no mess on the countertops or in the fridge from open dog food.
It was also great to make a huge saving but still get to feed fresh dog food to my Alaskan Klee Kai. I pay $218 a month to feed Sundays to Copper and Skye, which is a price increase in 2026 from previous years when we’ve reviewed their food.
Discover more about Sundays For Dogs?
I did a detail breakdown of their service here.
Who Are The Farmer’s Dog?
The Farmer’s Dog supplies fresh dog food to pups in the USA, with its delivery service rivaling competitors such as Nom Nom, Ollie and Spot & Tango.
Creating dog food tailored to your dog’s specific needs gives pet parents a chance to ditch dry, canned, raw and homemade dog food.
The Farmer’s Dog uses whole muscle and organ meats to make up the majority of their recipes, alongside green vegetables, fiber-rich foods, and supplemental nutrients.
Just like Sundays, their recipes have been formulated and approved by veterinarians, so you can feel confident your dog is eating balanced and complete meals.
Akin to most dog food subscription services, you’ll need to fill out their sign-up questionnaire to allow this fresh dog food delivery company to tailor your dog’s meals.
You can then decide which of their fresh food recipes you’d like for your canine companion. At the time of writing, The Farmer’s Dog offers a Beef recipe, Chicken recipe, Pork recipe and Turkey recipe to provide a range of ready-to-serve meals for picky eaters.
If you’re familiar with our social media and website, you’ll probably know that Copper and Skye have eaten fresh meals from Butternut Box for most of the past five years.
When we returned to the USA, we started our search for a new, fresh dog food delivery company that offered human-grade dog foods that prioritize a dog’s health. We had an initial shortlist that included The Farmer’s Dog, Nom Nom and Spot & Tango.
There’s no doubt that The Farmer’s Dog offers one of the better dog food delivery services. Of all the brands that we’ve tried, we felt that their dog food looked more like real human food than most, although we felt there were a couple of superior fresh dog food delivery services available.
I appreciated that The Farmer’s Dog labeled Copper and Skye’s individual meal pouches to highlight that my Klee Kai was eating dog food tailored to their weight goals. They use a portion guideline on the front of each meal packet to help dog owners feed the right amount at mealtime.
You’ll need to consider fridge and freezer space to store their human-grade dog food. The Farmer’s Dog uses long rectangular pouches that are relatively easy to stack in your freezer. You only need to keep two or three defrosted meal pouches in the fridge.
However, The Farmer’s Dog is an expensive dog food delivery service – there’s no escaping that fact. But they’re easily the most affordable among fresh dog food brands in the USA. At the time of writing, I paid $251.04 to receive fresh dog food for Copper and Skye each month.
Do you want to learn more about the brand?
Check out my dedicated review of The Farmer's Dog
Sundays Vs The Farmer’s Dog FAQ
The big difference between Sundays and The Farmer’s Dog is the type of pet food that they offer. Sundays is air-dried dog food. The Farmer’s Dog provides fresh dog food recipes.
Sundays and The Farmer’s Dog have both created recipes using human-grade ingredients, and they’re formulated to meet AAFCO nutritional standards.
Sundays are $66.64 cheaper per month than The Farmer’s Dog. There’s not a huge price difference.
Sundays are easier to store than The Farmer’s Dog because Sundays can be stored in the cupboard. The Farmer’s Dog needs to be kept in the freezer apart from a few defrosted pouches in the fridge.
Sundays and The Farmer’s Dog can be combined. It’s something we did for a little bit before we switched to a raw dog food brand.
Who Should Pick Which Brand?
Reasons to try Sundays for Dogs
- Your dog is particularly picky
- You want shelf-stable dog food
- You don’t want to use fridge or freezer space
- You travel a lot or value easy storage
- You want the cheaper option
- You like using air-dried food as a topper
Reasons to try The Farmer’s Dog
- Your dog loves the fresh dog food texture
- You want individually labeled dog food for your pack
- You care about having a portion guideline
- You’re looking for the cheapest fresh dog food subscription
- You’re accustomed to using fridge and freezer space for dog food
- You’re willing to pay a little more than a dry dog food subscription
Wrapping Up: Our Final Thoughts
We’ve reached the end of our comparison article. Based on our experience with Sundays For Dogs and The Farmer’s Dog, I’d recommend Sundays For Dogs.
I really liked how Sundays has a high meat content in the human-grade dog food. I believe this played a big part in Copper and Skye’s enthusiasm for their air-dried recipes.
It’s convenient to feed because it can be stored in a dry place like a cupboard, without sacrificing the freshness you’d expect from dog food subscriptions.
Sundays are also more affordable than human-grade fresh meals like The Farmer’s Dog.