5 Best Alternatives to The Farmer’s Dog (2026): Tested On Picky Dog
Key points
- Our experience: We’ve tested and reordered more than 30 dog food brands in the US with Skye and Copper, including all five alternatives featured in this guide.
- Best overall alternative: Sundays for Dogs is my top pick for convenience, texture, price, and convenience, with my Alaskan Klee Kai consistently enjoying it.
- Best for picky eaters: We Feed Raw got the best reaction from my fussy dog Skye, and she continues to eat it consistently two years after we first ordered it.
- Best budget option: UnKibble is the standout choice if you’re top priority is price and value. I paid $164.40 a month, and got a custom scooper for each of my Klee Kai.
- Best fresh alternative: Spot & Tango is the closest choice to The Farmer’s Dog if you want to stick with fresh dog food recipes.
- Important to know: The Farmer’s Dog is still my number one recommendation if you’re specifically looking for a fresh dog food sunscription.
Are you looking to end your subscription plan with The Farmer’s Dog in favor of a better or cheaper alternative?
Quick verdict
After testing a range of alternatives, Sundays for Dogs is the otption I’d choose for my dogs owners leaving The Farmer’s Dog and looking for a lower cost, more convenient option. However, if you’re quitting The Farmer’s Dog because of a picky eater, I’d recommend We Feed Raw because their frozen raw food transformed Skye from fussy to food motivated.
Since returning to California with my picky Alaskan Klee Kai dogs, Copper and Skye, in 2023, I’ve been testing a range of fresh, raw, and dry dog food options.
Fresh dog food can be expensive, and pet owners want to get the best bang for their buck while continuing to use human-grade food in their dog’s diet.
If you have a fussy eater like me, you may find that your picky eater has lost interest in The Farmer’s Dog and needs to find some new fresh dog food brands to reignite their mealtime motivation.
In this article, we’ll examine the best alternatives to The Farmer’s Dog for pet owners who want to continue feeding fresh dog food but are open to trying other brands.
My selections are based on ongoing ordering, testing, and reordering from over 30 dog food brands in the USA to keep our content updated.
Show table of contents Hide table of contents
Watch: The Best Farmer’s Dog Alternatives Tested with Our Dogs
1) Sundays For Dogs
I believe Sundays For Dogs is a great option for pet parents who want to feed fresh food made with human-grade ingredients without the expense and hassle sometimes associated with fresh dog food like The Farmer’s Dog.
Sundays has three recipes (beef, chicken, and turkey) formulated by veterinary nutritionists and containing human-grade ingredients. They gently air-dry their recipes before shipping them directly to your door.
Unlike The Farmer’s Dog, Sundays doesn’t require fridge or freezer space. You simply open the bag on Sundays, pour directly into your dog’s bowl, reseal the bag, and pop it back in the cupboard. I love the convenience of their air-dried food compared to fresh dog food.
Pet owners can save money because Sundays are cheaper than The Farmer’s Dog. Feeding Sundays to Copper and Skye costs me $184.40 a month, which is nearly $10 cheaper than The Farmer’s Dog. That’s a savings of $120 over the course of a year.
While my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs love eating fresh frozen meals such as The Farmer’s Dog, I was pleasantly surprised to see how much they loved eating Sundays and finished their air-dried food at mealtime.
Copper and Skye consistently finish their Sunday food, and we continue to feed this brand alongside We Feed Raw. So that’s over three years of Sundays!
Pros
- Shelf-stable and doesn’t require fridge or freezer space
- Cheaper than The Farmer’s Dog and We Feed Raw in my testing
- Skye and Copper consistently finished their Sundays meals over a year
- Easy to serve with mininal prep required
Cons
- Only three recipes (beef, chicken and turkey)
- More expensive than traditional pet food formats such as kibble
- Lacks customization compared to competitors like UnKibble
- Only available through its website
2) We Feed Raw
We Feed Raw is one of the best raw food companies that we’ve tested on our Klee Kai dogs.
While raw feeding can be intimidating to some pet owners, We Feed Raw makes it simple to introduce it to your dog’s diet. They also offer freeze-dried raw if you want the benefits of a raw diet without the perceived hassle.
We Feed Raw has more recipes than The Farmer’s Dog. You can select from six protein sources, which is a big bonus for a dog like Skye, who is such a picky eater.
Unlike some raw food companies, We Feed Raw uses meal pouches to store your dog’s raw food.
In 2026, they launched peel-back pouches to make life even easier! I was grateful no more scissors were required to get Copper and Skye’s food ready.`
My Klee Kai are obsessed with We Feed Raw, which was incredible because Skye is a fussy pup. She devoured her We Feed Raw meals and made sure Copper couldn’t get near her bowl!
I pay $202.20 for Copper and Skye’s subscription, which is more expensive than The Farmer’s Dog but worth the extra cost, seeing as my Klee Kai loves We Feed Raw.
To see how We Feed Raw compares to The Farmer's Dog, you can read my detailed article.
Pros
- Excellent choice for picky eaters
- Five protein options to appeal to fussy dogs like Skye
- Peel-back pouches make serving easier than before
- Frozen raw and freeze-dried recipes
Cons
- More expensive than The Farmer’s Dog
- Frozen raw food requires freezer space and thawing in the fridge
- Raw feeding can require more handling and prepartion
- No custom scooper
3) UnKibble
If you previously fed dry food before switching to fresh dog food, you may want to go back. However, you don’t need to return to store-bought food.
There are plenty of dog food subscription services providing elevated dry dog food. UnKibble is one such fresh food brand.
UnKibble is a dry food product made by Spot and Tango as part of their popular dog food delivery service. I like UnKibble’s limited-ingredient recipes, clear labeling, and customization. They’ve got four recipes: Beef & Barley, Chicken & Brown Rice, Cod & Salmon, and Turkey & Sweet Potato.
UnKibble offers a customized scooper to help your dog achieve a healthy weight and promote its health. They’re one of the only brands to offer a custom scooper, which I love because it takes the guesswork out of mealtime.
If you’re signing up for a new dog food delivery plan, you must provide the brand with key details about your dog, such as age, breed, activity level, food allergies, and more.
Copper and Skye have enjoyed UnKibble every time we’ve tested their dry food to keep our content updated.
I paid $164.40 a month for UnKibble for my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs, which is $30 cheaper than The Farmer’s Dog. Over the course of a year, UnKibble will save pet owners $228.
Pros
- Cheaper than The Farmer’s Dog and most competitors we tested
- No fridge or freezer space required
- Custom scooper makes portioning and meal prep a breeze
- Copper and Skye have consistently eaten their beef recipe
Cons
- More expensive than traditional kibble
- Dry food won’t suit picky dogs who have become bored with this format
- Limited recipe range
- Fish recipe wasn’t a hit with my Alaskan Klee Kai
4) Tally’s Ranch
There are many fresh food brands in the American pet food industry, and some dog owners might want to try raw dog food, but don’t want the hassle. We found Tally’s Ranch to be a convenient alternative that gives the benefits of raw without the mess.
Tally’s Ranch offers freeze-dried raw dog food made from human-grade ingredients, similar to the best fresh dog food brands. They freeze-dry their recipes to ensure that all the nutritional goodness is locked in.
At the time of writing, Tally’s Ranch offers only two protein sources: beef and chicken. Typically, we’d look for a larger recipe range to satisfy my fussy Alaskan Klee Kai, Skye. However, she liked Tally’s Ranch after a month of testing their food.
Tally’s Ranch doesn’t require freezer space, so you don’t need to worry about defrosting food or making space in your refrigerator. You can serve it directly from the bag into your dog’s bowl. Tally’s Ranch provides a scooper, but it isn’t a custom scooper like UnKibble.
Having fed fresh dog food for nearly 5 years, I was reluctant to switch to a subscription. However, I’ve seen so many benefits since switching to raw dog food. Tally’s Ranch is a good option if you want to embrace raw, but you’re not ready to handle and store raw dog food.
Tally’s Ranch costs more than The Farmer’s Dog. I paid $219 a month to feed it to my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs.
We compared The Farmer's Dog and Tally's Ranch in this detailed comparison article
Pros
- Freeze-dried raw without the storage hassle of frozen raw food
- No fridge, freezer or thawing required
- Easy to serve straight from the bag
- Skye liked it during testing
Cons
- No custom scooper
- More expensive than We Feed Raw’s freeze-dried food
- Don’t provide a custom scooper
- Only two recipes: beef and chicken
5) Spot & Tango
If you want to stick with fresh dog foods, you could switch from The Farmer’s Dog to Spot & Tango. They’re our second-favorite fresh dog food brand.
I can understand why some dog owners will be reluctant to move away from fresh foods if they’ve seen their dog’s eating habits or health transformed by them.
Spot & Tango offers fresh dog food delivery alongside their UnKibble range. You can pick from Turkey & Red Quinoa, Beef & Millet, and Lamb & Brown Rice. It’s one recipe less than The Farmer’s Dog.
Like UnKibble, Spot & Tango use limited-ingredient recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists. They are gently cooked, tailored to your dog’s specific requirements, and delivered to your door.
Spot & Tango is considered one of the best fresh dog food delivery companies in the USA, alongside The Farmer’s Dog. While my dogs preferred The Farmer’s Dog, you may find your pup prefers something else.
However, Spot & Tango is more expensive than The Farmer’s Dog. I paid $300.48 for Spot & Tango, which is $50 more than The Farmer’s Dog’s monthly price. Admittedly, that’s a big difference!
Pros
- One of the closest like-for-like alternatives to Farmer’s Dog
- Personalized meal plans
- Limited-ingredint recipes
- Transparent labeling and high-quality ingredients
Cons
- Significantly more expensive than the Farmer’s Dog
- Only three fresh food recipes
- Copper and Skye preferred The Farmer’s Dog
- Denser texture than The Farmer’s Dog
Reasons To Stick With The Farmer’s Dog
If you’re thinking about ditching The Farmer’s Dog, you may want to think twice. Having reviewed many fresh dog food delivery companies over the past seven years, they’re arguably the best fresh dog food.
I really like that The Farmer’s Dog offers a portion guideline on the front of their fresh dog food meal pouches. I haven’t seen any other fresh food companies incorporate this idea.
When I signed up for The Farmer’s Dog, I entered Copper and Skye’s information as I do with every fresh dog food brand.
However, The Farmer’s Dog is the only brand that provides individually labeled meal packets. This highlights to me that The Farmer’s Dog is truly working to achieve your dog’s weight goals.
The Farmer’s Dog is the best-priced fresh dog food brand. I haven’t reviewed other dog food companies that quoted less than $260 for their service.
Note: The prices shown above are based on Copper and Skye, two Alaskan Klee Kai dogs, weighing 15lbs each.
The Farmer’s Dog Alternatives FAQ
The Farmer’s Dog is a fresh dog food company, so their direct competitors include Spot and Tango, Ollie, The Pets Table and Nom Nom.
We’ve reviewed all of these brands directly against The Farmer’s Dog, and the winner is The Farmer’s Dog for price, service and taste.
The Farmer’s Dog is better than Ollie in my experience, based on my Alaskan Klee Kai’s preference and value for money.
However, Ollie offers more recipes and both fresh and dry dog food. You can also purchase Ollie at your local pet store.
The Farmer’s Dog is expensive because they offer custom meal plans, using high-quality ingredientw, and deliver their food directly to your door.
The Farmer’s Dog is cheaper than The Pets Table, based on ordering from both dog food companies for my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs.
I paid $251.04 for The Farmer’s Dog, but The Pets Table cost me $273.60.
Wrapping Up
We’ve reached the end of our article looking at the best alternatives to The Farmer’s Dog.
I’ve highlighted five brands I like when searching for dog food brands similar to The Farmer’s Dog.
My top pick is Sundays For Dogs based on the price, passing the taste test, and overall service.
However, if you care just about your picky eater loving their food, I’d go for We Feed Raw. They transformed Skye from fussy to a food lover!
But I don’t think you’ll go wrong if you choose Tally’s Ranch, We Feed Raw, UnKibble or Spot and Tango.